Comparison of allergen-induced late inflammatory reactions in the nose and in the skin in house dust mite-allergic patients with or without asthma

Background: It remains to be established which factors contribute to the occurrence of asthma in allergic individuals. We hypothesized that differences in the late allergic inflammatory reaction to allergen between asthmatic and non-asthmatic house dust mite-allergic individuals might contribute to the difference in the clinical presentation of allergy.

Aim: To compare allergen-induced changes in parameters for cellular inflammation during the phase of the late allergic reaction in the skin and nose, in house dust mite-allergic individuals with or without asthma.

Material and methods: Nasal and dermal allergen challenges with house dust mite (Dermatophagoides pteronyssinus) extract were performed in 52 house dust mite-allergic individuals, of whom 26 had mild to moderate persistent asthma and 26 had perennial rhinitis without current or past asthmatic symptoms. Serial nasal lavage samples were analyzed for the presence of inflammatory cells (eosinophils and neutrophils) and soluble markers associated with cellular inflammation [interleukin-5 (IL-5), interleukin-8 (IL-8), eosinophil cationic protein (ECP) and myeloperoxidase (MPO)]. Macroscopic late phase skin reactions were studied after intracutaneous skin tests with house dust mite extract.

Results: Fixed dose nasal allergen provocation elicited a similar degree of immediate allergic reaction as judged by plasma protein exudation and histamine concentrations in asthma and non-asthmatic rhinitis. Subsequently, no differences between groups were found during the phase of the late allergic reaction (4-24 h) in inflammatory cell influx, plasma protein leakage, ECP or MPO. Likewise, there were no differences in levels of chemotactic cytokines IL-5 and IL-8. In agreement with the results of nasal challenge, the late skin reaction after dermal challenge with a fixed allergen dose and after an allergen dose 10,000 times above the skin threshold for an early skin reaction did not differ between the groups.

Conclusion: House dust mite-allergic patients with or without asthma have very similar late allergic inflammatory reactions in the skin and in the nose after allergen challenge. Hence, it is unlikely that the occurrence of pulmonary symptoms in asthma is explained by a general tendency of asthmatics to have an enhanced late allergic cellular inflammatory response. Nasal and dermal allergen provocations are adequate models to study allergen-induced inflammation but probably lack the pivotal link which is essential for the development of asthma.