The endogenous methylarginines asymmetric dimethylarginine (ADMA) and N(G)-monomethyl-L-arginine (L-NMMA) regulate nitric oxide (NO) production from neuronal NO synthase (nNOS). Under conditions of L-arginine or tetrahydrobiopterin (BH(4)) depletion, nNOS also generates superoxide, O(2)(.); however, the effects of methylarginines on this O(2)(.) generation are poorly understood. Therefore, we measured the dose-dependent effects of ADMA and L-NMMA on the rate and amount of O(2)(.) production from nNOS under conditions of L-arginine and/or BH(4) depletion, using electron paramagnetic resonance spin trapping. In the absence of L-arginine, ADMA (1 microm) inhibited O(2)(.) generation by approximately 60% from a rate of 56 to 23 nmol/mg/min, whereas L-NMMA (0.1-100 microm) had no effect. L-Arginine markedly decreased the observed O(2)(.) adduct formation; however, O(2)(.) generation from the enzyme still occurs at a low rate (12.1 nmol/mg/min). This O(2)(.) leak is NOS-derived as it is not seen in the absence of calcium and calmodulin and demonstrates that O(2)(.) generation from NOS occurs even when normal substrate/ cofactor levels are present. Under conditions of BH(4) depletion, ADMA had no effect on O(2)(.), whereas L-NMMA increased O(2)(.) production almost 3-fold. This O(2)(.) generation was >90% inhibited by imidazole, indicating that it occurred at the heme center. Thus, methylarginines can profoundly shift the balance of NO and O(2)(.) generation from nNOS. These observations have important implications with regard to the therapeutic use of methylarginine-NOS inhibitors in the treatment of disease.