Background: Many laboratories use the DNA Hybrid Capture 2 HPV-high risk assay (Digene) to detect and type oncogenic HPV. The aim of this work was to compare this assay with a new HPV genotyping assay: HPV Consensus kit (Argène). Actually, this assay is not commercially available.
Materials and methods: Ninety-four cervical samples were tested with both the routine assay Hybrid Capture 2 and the HPV Consensus kit. Discordant results were analysed by amplification with a nested PCR and sequencing of amplified products.
Results: Only 81 results could be analysed concerning the oncogenic risk. The overall concordance was 92,6%. But we find 13 "generic" results with the HPV Consensus kit, the generic probe including high risk and low risk genotypes.
Conclusion: HPV Consensus kit results showed a better detection sensitivity for this assay than Hybrid Capture 2 assay. Nevertheless, "generic" results give no information about the oncogenic risk of the HPV detected in a sample.