Employing 1,3-dipolar cycloaddition for the synthesis of the 7a-azaindole nucleus, analogues of melatonin have been synthesized and tested against human and amphibian melatonin receptors. Introducing a phenyl substituent in position 2 of the heterocyclic moiety significantly increased binding affinity to both the MT1 and MT2 receptors. Shifting the methoxy group from position 5 to 2 of the 7a-azaindole ring led to a substantial reduction of MT1 binding when MT2 recognition was maintained. We theoretically investigated the hypothesis whether the 2-methoxy function of the azamelatonin analogue 27 is able to mimic the 5-methoxy group of the neurohormone by directing its 2-methoxy function toward the methoxy binding site. DFT calculations and experimental binding differences of analogue compounds indicate that the energy gained by forming the methoxy-specific hydrogen-bond interaction should exceed the energy required for adopting an alternative conformation.