Measuring the statistical distribution of deuterium incorporated into enzymatically derived peptide fragments provides a valuable dimension to hydrogen/deuterium exchange mass spectrometry data. In this paper, we will discuss our improvement to the linear least-squares method for determining this distribution, through the addition of "zeroes" to the end of the deuterated isotopic envelope, to partially compensate for data truncation due to finite instrumental signal-to-noise ratios. The value of the distribution is demonstrated in a simple experimental example, where the linearity between average deuteration and percent D2O used to label test peptides hides a more complex relationship between the site-labeling probability and the total number of sites. This method offers the opportunity to resolve cases where a single peptide experiences distinct, independent biochemical states with each bearing a unique average deuteration; this can occur when a protein is modified to substoichiometric levels. From the experimentally determined distribution of a heterogeneously deuterated peptide, it was possible to extract the average deuteration of each component of the mixture.