We have investigated the ionization threshold behavior of small helium cluster ions (cluster size n=2-10) formed via electron-impact ionization of neutral helium droplets and derive appearance energies for mass-selected cluster ions using a nonlinear least-square-fitting procedure. Moreover, we report magic numbers in the mass spectrum observed at the electron energy of 70 eV. The apparatus used for the present measurements is a hemispherical electron monochromator combined with a quadrupole mass spectrometer. Our experiment demonstrates that helium clusters are not only exclusively formed via direct ionization above the atomic ionization potential but also indirectly via autoionizing Rydberg states. The present results are compared with previous electron-impact and photoionization results.