Dual ligand stimulation of RAW 264.7 cells uncovers feedback mechanisms that regulate TLR-mediated gene expression

J Immunol. 2006 Oct 1;177(7):4299-310. doi: 10.4049/jimmunol.177.7.4299.

Abstract

To characterize how signaling by TLR ligands can be modulated by non-TLR ligands, murine RAW 264.7 cells were treated with LPS, IFN-gamma, 2-methyl-thio-ATP (2MA), PGE(2), and isoproterenol (ISO). Ligands were applied individually and in combination with LPS, for 1, 2, and 4 h, and transcriptional changes were measured using customized oligo arrays. We used nonadditive transcriptional responses to dual ligands (responses that were reproducibly greater or less than the expected additive responses) as a measure of pathway interaction. Our analysis suggests that cross-talk is limited; <24% of the features with significant responses to the single ligands responded nonadditively to a dual ligand pair. PGE(2) and ISO mainly attenuated, while 2MA enhanced, LPS-induced transcriptional changes. IFN-gamma and LPS cross-regulated the transcriptional response induced by each other: while LPS preferentially enhanced IFN-gamma-induced changes in gene expression at 1 h, IFN-gamma signaling primarily attenuated LPS-induced changes at 4 h. Our data suggest specific cross-talk mechanisms: 1) LPS enhances the expression of IFN-gamma-response genes by augmenting STAT1 activity and by activating NF-kappaB, which synergizes with IFN-gamma-induced transcriptional factors; 2) IFN-gamma attenuates the late LPS transcriptional response by increasing the expression of suppressor of cytokine signaling 1 and cytokine-inducible SH2-containing protein expression; 3) 2MA modulates LPS secondary transcriptional response by increasing IFN-beta and inhibiting IL-10 gene expression; 4) PGE(2) and ISO similarly regulate the LPS transcriptional response. They increase IL-10 transcription, resulting in attenuated expression of known IL-10-suppressed genes.

Publication types

  • Research Support, N.I.H., Extramural

MeSH terms

  • Adenosine Triphosphate / analogs & derivatives
  • Adenosine Triphosphate / immunology
  • Adenosine Triphosphate / metabolism
  • Animals
  • Cell Line
  • Dinoprostone / immunology
  • Dinoprostone / metabolism
  • Gene Expression Regulation / immunology*
  • Gene Expression*
  • Interferon-gamma / immunology
  • Interferon-gamma / metabolism
  • Isoproterenol / immunology
  • Isoproterenol / metabolism
  • Ligands
  • Lipopolysaccharides / immunology
  • Lipopolysaccharides / metabolism
  • Mice
  • Oligonucleotide Array Sequence Analysis
  • Receptor Cross-Talk / immunology*
  • Signal Transduction / immunology*
  • Thionucleotides / immunology
  • Thionucleotides / metabolism
  • Toll-Like Receptors / biosynthesis*
  • Toll-Like Receptors / genetics*
  • Transcription, Genetic / drug effects

Substances

  • Ligands
  • Lipopolysaccharides
  • Thionucleotides
  • Toll-Like Receptors
  • Interferon-gamma
  • Adenosine Triphosphate
  • Dinoprostone
  • Isoproterenol
  • 2-methylthio-ATP

Associated data

  • GEO/GSM111939
  • GEO/GSM111940
  • GEO/GSM111941
  • GEO/GSM111942
  • GEO/GSM111943
  • GEO/GSM111944
  • GEO/GSM111945
  • GEO/GSM111946
  • GEO/GSM111947
  • GEO/GSM111948
  • GEO/GSM111949
  • GEO/GSM111950
  • GEO/GSM111951
  • GEO/GSM111952
  • GEO/GSM111953
  • GEO/GSM111954
  • GEO/GSM111955
  • GEO/GSM111956
  • GEO/GSM111957
  • GEO/GSM111958
  • GEO/GSM111959
  • GEO/GSM111960
  • GEO/GSM111961
  • GEO/GSM111962
  • GEO/GSM111963
  • GEO/GSM111964
  • GEO/GSM111965
  • GEO/GSM111966
  • GEO/GSM111967
  • GEO/GSM111968
  • GEO/GSM111969
  • GEO/GSM111970
  • GEO/GSM111971
  • GEO/GSM111972
  • GEO/GSM111973
  • GEO/GSM111974
  • GEO/GSM111975
  • GEO/GSM111976
  • GEO/GSM111977
  • GEO/GSM111978
  • GEO/GSM111979
  • GEO/GSM111980
  • GEO/GSM111981
  • GEO/GSM111982
  • GEO/GSM111983
  • GEO/GSM111984
  • GEO/GSM111985
  • GEO/GSM111986
  • GEO/GSM111987
  • GEO/GSM111988
  • GEO/GSM111989
  • GEO/GSM111990
  • GEO/GSM111991
  • GEO/GSM111992
  • GEO/GSM111993
  • GEO/GSM111994
  • GEO/GSM111995
  • GEO/GSM111996
  • GEO/GSM111997
  • GEO/GSM111998
  • GEO/GSM111999
  • GEO/GSM112000
  • GEO/GSM112001
  • GEO/GSM112002
  • GEO/GSM112003
  • GEO/GSM112004
  • GEO/GSM112005
  • GEO/GSM112006
  • GEO/GSM112007
  • GEO/GSM112008
  • GEO/GSM112009
  • GEO/GSM112010
  • GEO/GSM112011
  • GEO/GSM112012
  • GEO/GSM112013
  • GEO/GSM112014
  • GEO/GSM112015
  • GEO/GSM112016
  • GEO/GSM112017
  • GEO/GSM112018
  • GEO/GSM112019
  • GEO/GSM112020
  • GEO/GSM112021
  • GEO/GSM112022
  • GEO/GSM112023
  • GEO/GSM112024
  • GEO/GSM112025
  • GEO/GSM112026
  • GEO/GSM112027
  • GEO/GSM112028
  • GEO/GSM112042
  • GEO/GSM112043
  • GEO/GSM112044
  • GEO/GSM112045
  • GEO/GSM112046
  • GEO/GSM112047
  • GEO/GSM112048
  • GEO/GSM112049
  • GEO/GSM112050
  • GEO/GSM112051
  • GEO/GSM112052
  • GEO/GSM112053
  • GEO/GSM112054
  • GEO/GSM112055
  • GEO/GSM112056
  • GEO/GSM112057
  • GEO/GSM112058
  • GEO/GSM112059
  • GEO/GSM112060
  • GEO/GSM112061
  • GEO/GSM112062
  • GEO/GSM112063
  • GEO/GSM112064
  • GEO/GSM112065
  • GEO/GSM112066
  • GEO/GSM112067
  • GEO/GSM112068
  • GEO/GSM112069
  • GEO/GSM112070
  • GEO/GSM112071
  • GEO/GSM112072
  • GEO/GSM112073
  • GEO/GSM112074
  • GEO/GSM112075
  • GEO/GSM112076
  • GEO/GSM112077
  • GEO/GSM112078
  • GEO/GSM112079
  • GEO/GSM112080
  • GEO/GSM112081
  • GEO/GSM112082
  • GEO/GSM112083
  • GEO/GSM112084
  • GEO/GSM112085
  • GEO/GSM112086
  • GEO/GSM112087
  • GEO/GSM112088
  • GEO/GSM112089
  • GEO/GSM112090
  • GEO/GSM112091
  • GEO/GSM112092
  • GEO/GSM112093
  • GEO/GSM112094
  • GEO/GSM112095
  • GEO/GSM112096
  • GEO/GSM112097
  • GEO/GSM112098
  • GEO/GSM112099
  • GEO/GSM112100
  • GEO/GSM112101
  • GEO/GSM112102
  • GEO/GSM112103
  • GEO/GSM112104
  • GEO/GSM112105
  • GEO/GSM112106
  • GEO/GSM112107
  • GEO/GSM112108
  • GEO/GSM112109
  • GEO/GSM112110
  • GEO/GSM112111
  • GEO/GSM112112
  • GEO/GSM112113
  • GEO/GSM112114
  • GEO/GSM112115
  • GEO/GSM112116
  • GEO/GSM112117
  • GEO/GSM112118
  • GEO/GSM112119
  • GEO/GSM112120
  • GEO/GSM112121
  • GEO/GSM112122
  • GEO/GSM112123
  • GEO/GSM112124
  • GEO/GSM112125
  • GEO/GSM112126
  • GEO/GSM112127
  • GEO/GSM112128
  • GEO/GSM112129
  • GEO/GSM18191
  • GEO/GSM18192
  • GEO/GSM18193
  • GEO/GSM18194
  • GEO/GSM18195
  • GEO/GSM18196
  • GEO/GSM18197
  • GEO/GSM18198
  • GEO/GSM18199
  • GEO/GSM18200
  • GEO/GSM18201
  • GEO/GSM18202
  • GEO/GSM18203
  • GEO/GSM18204
  • GEO/GSM18205
  • GEO/GSM18206
  • GEO/GSM18207
  • GEO/GSM18208
  • GEO/GSM18209
  • GEO/GSM18210
  • GEO/GSM18211
  • GEO/GSM18212
  • GEO/GSM18213
  • GEO/GSM18214
  • GEO/GSM18215
  • GEO/GSM18216
  • GEO/GSM18217
  • GEO/GSM18218
  • GEO/GSM18219
  • GEO/GSM18220
  • GEO/GSM18221
  • GEO/GSM18222
  • GEO/GSM18223
  • GEO/GSM18224
  • GEO/GSM18225
  • GEO/GSM18226