A structure for the self-condensation product of 2-(1H-indol-2-yl)ethyl tosylate 2a, previously proposed as 6,7,14,15-tetrahydro-15aH-azocino[1,2-a:6,5-b]diindole 3a, was revised based on the (13)C-2D-INADEQUATE experiment, and proved to be 7,7a,13,14-tetrahydro-6H-cyclobuta[b]pyrimido[1,2-a:3,4-a']diindole 4a. A mechanism for the unexpected formation of this novel hexacyclic heterocycle was proposed and its NMR solution structure was elucidated. Five derivatives of the title ring skeleton 12-16 designed as melatonin receptor ligands were synthesized and their affinities for the human MT(1) and MT(2) receptors were determined. Both butyramides 13 and 15, as well as the non-methoxy acetamide 12 exhibited micromolar binding affinities for both receptors being slightly MT(2) selective. The methoxy acetamide 14 showed the best pharmacological profile exhibiting a five times higher affinity for MT(1) (K(i) = 49 nM) than for MT(2) (K(i) = 246 nM) receptor.