CTL are important for virus clearance but also contribute to immunopathology after the infection of BALB/c mice with respiratory syncytial virus (RSV). The pulmonary immune response to RSV is dominated by a CTL population directed against the CTL epitope M2-1 82-90. Infection with a virus carrying an M2-1 N89A mutation introduced by reverse genetics failed to activate this immunodominant CTL population, leading to a significant decrease in the overall antiviral CTL response. There was no compensatory increase in responses to the mutated epitope, to the subdominant epitope F 85-93, or to yet undefined minor epitopes in the N or the P protein. However, there was some increase in the response to the subdominant epitope M2-1 127-135, which is located in the same protein and presented by the same H-2Kd MHC molecule. Infection with the mutant virus reversed the oligoclonality of the T cell response elicited by the wild-type virus. These changes in the pattern and composition of the antiviral CTL response only slightly impaired virus clearance but significantly reduced RSV-induced weight loss. These data illustrate how T cell epitope mutations can influence the virus-host relationship and determine disease after an acute respiratory virus infection.