We study the statistics of return intervals between events above a certain threshold in multifractal data sets without linear correlations. We find that nonlinear correlations in the record lead to a power-law (i) decay of the autocorrelation function of the return intervals, (ii) increase in the conditional return period, and (iii) decay in the probability density function of the return intervals. We show explicitly that all the observed quantities depend both on the threshold value and system size, and hence there is no simple scaling observed. We also demonstrate that this type of behavior can be observed in real economic records and can be used to improve considerably risk estimation.