The biochemical basis for S9-dependent mutagenic response of the 5-HT(2C) receptor agonist and diazinylpiperazine derivative 1 in the Salmonella Ames assay involves P450-mediated bioactivation to DNA-reactive quinone-methide, aldehyde and nitrone intermediates. Mechanistic information pertaining to the metabolism of 1 was used in the design of diazinylpiperazine 5 to eliminate the safety liability. While 5 was negative in the Ames assay, the compound retained the ability of 1 to form certain electrophilic intermediates. Plausible hypotheses that can collectively account for the differences in mutagenic response of the two piperazine analogs are discussed.