Novel biomechanical methods have been developed to objectively measure acute fracture severity (from inter-fragmentary surface area) and chronic contact stress challenge (from patient-specific finite element analysis) in articular fractures. These new methods help clarify the pathomechanics of the development of post-traumatic osteoarthritis, and can contribute directly to the clinical care of patients. In this manuscript, the value of these two new measures is demonstrated in three illustrative tibial plafond fracture cases, in which both metrics are correlated with cartilage status and with patient outcomes at a minimum of two years after injury. These clinical cases demonstrate the utility of new biomechanical variables to advance clinical research and patient care, by providing a basis to predict outcome and select treatment.