Induction therapy is used in kidney transplantation to inhibit the activation of donor-reactive T cells which are detrimental to transplant outcomes. The choice of induction therapy is decided based on perceived immunological risk rather than by direct measurement of donor T-cell reactivity. We hypothesized that immune cellular alloreactivity pretransplantation can be quantified and that blocking versus depleting therapies have differential effects on the level of donor and third-party cellular alloreactivity. We studied 31 kidney transplant recipients treated with either antithymocyte globulin (ATG) or an IL-2 receptor blocker. We tested pre- and posttransplant peripheral blood cells by flow cytometry to characterize T-cell populations and by IFN-γ ELISPOT assays to assess the level of cellular alloreactivity. CD8(+) T cells were more resistant to depletion by ATG than CD4(+) T cells. Posttransplantation, frequencies of donor-reactive T cells were markedly decreased in the ATG-treated group but not in the IL-2 receptor blocker group, whereas the frequencies of third-party alloreactivity remained nearly equivalent. In conclusion, when ATG is used, marked and prolonged donor hyporesponsiveness with minimal effects on nondonor responses is observed. In contrast, induction with the IL-2 receptor blocker is less effective at diminishing donor T-cell reactivity.
2011 The American Society of Transplantation and the American Society of Transplant Surgeons.