We compare the aqueous self-assembly behavior within the homologous peptide series AnK, where A is alanine, K is lysine, and n = 4, 6, 8, and 10. The aqueous peptide solubility, ϕ(s) (volume fraction), depends strongly on the number of hydrophobic alanine residues and decreases approximately as ϕ(s) ≈ 10(-n). Also the self-assembly structure depends on n. A4K is highly water-soluble and shows no relevant self-assembly. A6K, which has been extensively studied previously, forms hollow nanotubes in water. A8K and A10K self-assembly is characterized here using a combination of small- and wide-angle X-ray scattering, static and dynamic light scattering, cryo transmission electron microscopy, and circular dichroism spectroscopy. They both form similar thin rodlike aggregates with lengths on the order of 100 nm and a biaxial cross-section with dimensions of 4 nm × 8 nm. We show that different sample preparation protocols result in different lengths of the A10K rodlike aggregates. On the basis of these findings, the question of thermodynamic equilibrium of peptide self-assembly is discussed.