Short ragweeds is highly cross-reactive with other ragweeds

Background: The most widespread ragweed (Ambrosia) species in North America are short ragweed (Ambrosia artemisiifolia; Amb a), giant ragweed (Ambrosia trifida; Amb t), and western ragweed (Ambrosia psilostachya; Amb p). Varied geographic distributions of ragweed species raise questions regarding the need for ragweed species-specific allergen immunotherapy.

Objective: To determine allergenic cross-reactivity among ragweed species by immunologic analyses of sera from subjects allergic to ragweed from North America and Europe.

Methods: Sera were collected from 452 subjects allergic to ragweed who participated in Amb a sublingual immunotherapy tablet clinical trials. All subjects had positive skin prick test and serum IgE against Amb a. Ragweed-specific IgE (pre treatment) and IgG4 (post treatment) were measured by ImmunoCAP. IgE inhibition studies among Amb a, Amb t, and Amb p were conducted. Using pooled sera from another ragweed-allergic population, IgE inhibition studies of 7 less widespread Ambrosia species also were conducted.

Results: A strong correlation between Amb a vs Amb p and Amb t serum IgE levels was observed. In the vast majority of pretreatment sera, Amb a inhibited Amb a, Amb p, and Amb t IgE reactivity by more than 90%. Strong correlations were observed between Amb a vs Amb p and Amb t post-treatment IgG4 levels. In pooled sera, Amb a extract inhibited the binding of serum IgE to all 10 ragweed species by 98%-100%.

Conclusion: In a population of subjects allergic to Amb a, substantial allergenic cross-reactivity among Amb a, Amb p, and Amb t was demonstrated. These in vitro data suggest that an Amb a-based single-species ragweed allergen immunotherapy may be therapeutically active in patients exposed to diverse ragweed pollens.

Trial registry: Clinicaltrials.gov, NCT00770315, NCT00783198, and NCT00330083.