Microfluidic devices can be used to produce single, double and higher order emulsions, where droplet sizes can be precisely controlled and modulated. Such emulsions have great potential for the storage and study of biomolecules, including peptides and proteins. However, advancement of this technique has remained challenging due to the tendency of various biomolecules to adhere to the surface of the formed channels, resulting in changes in surface wetting and fouling on the micrometer scale. Thus, precise control of surface wettability plays a crucial role in the processes that govern droplet formation. Here, we report an approach for producing both water-oil-water (w/o/w) and oil-water-oil (o/w/o) double emulsions without any need for surface modification, an enabling feature for biomolecular encapsulation. Using this strategy, we show that the number of monodisperse encapsulated internal droplets can be controlled systematically and reproducibly by suitable adjustment of the relevant flow rates, and ranges from 1 to 40 in the case of w/o/w emulsions. We further demonstrate that the number of internal droplets scales linearly with the reciprocal flow rate of the outer continuous phase, when the inner and middle phase flow rates are kept constant. We demonstrate that this approach is suitable for forming double emulsions where the inner phase consists of reconstituted silk protein solution whereby incubation of the internal droplets can be induced to form a gel resulting in silk fibroin microgels surrounded by an external oil shell. Finally, for o/w/o emulsions, we show that single or multiple monodisperse internal droplets can be encapsulated with a size that ranges over 1 order of magnitude, from ca. 10 μm to >100 μm. Moreover, o/w/o emulsions where the middle phase consists of silk fibroin solution were prepared and by allowing the protein to aggregate, a core-shell structure was formed. This microfluidic strategy allows for multiple emulsions to be generated drop by drop for biomolecular solutions with potential applications in the biomedical and pharmaceutical fields.