Subclinical hypothyroidism: new trials, old caveats

The indications for levothyroxine replacement therapy for subclinical hypothyroidism (SH) remain a subject of debate, especially when prescribed for older adults. The results of the recent TRUST trial indicate that levothyroxine does not improve clinical symptom scores among elderly patients with SH. While there is much concern regarding the dilemma of introducing or withholding levothyroxine, less attention may be paid to the differential diagnosis of an elevated TSH level, which is the prerequisite for diagnosing SH. Herein, we review these issues facing endocrinologists and internists/generalists either in practice or in training. When a patient presents abnormal thyroid test results compatible with SH, a series of issues need to be addressed before the implementation of replacement therapy is considered: first, an isolated TSH elevation not linked to a primary thyroid pathology should be excluded; second, the persistent nature of the patient's TSH elevation and SH profile should be verified; third, SH symptoms and potential complications relevant for the specific patient should be documented; fourth, expectations from levothyroxine substitution therapy for SH in the specific patient should be clarified. Only then can the decision be made whether levothyroxine substitution should be introduced or not.