Measurements of the stable isotope ratios of nitrogen (15N/14N) and oxygen (18O/16O) in nitrate (NO3-) enable identification of sources, dispersal, and fate of natural and contaminant NO3- in aquatic environments. The 18O/16O of NO3- produced by nitrification is often assumed to reflect the proportional contribution of oxygen atom sources, water, and molecular oxygen, in a 2:1 ratio. Culture and seawater incubations, however, indicate oxygen isotopic equilibration between nitrite (NO2-) and water, and kinetic isotope effects for oxygen atom incorporation, which modulate the NO3- 18O/16O produced during nitrification. To investigate the influence of kinetic and equilibrium effects on the isotopic composition of NO3- produced from the nitrification of ammonia (NH3), we incubated streamwater supplemented with ammonium (NH4+) and increments of 18O-enriched water. Resulting NO3- 18O/16O ratios showed (1) a disproportionate sensitivity to the 18O/16O ratio of water, mediated by isotopic equilibration between water and NO2-, as well as (2) kinetic isotope discrimination during O atom incorporation from molecular oxygen and water. Empirically, the NO3- 18O/16O ratios thus produced fortuitously converge near the 18O/16O ratio of water. More elevated NO3- 18O/16O values commonly reported in soils and oxic groundwater may thus derive from processes additional to nitrification, including NO3- reduction.