Objective: To investigate application and safety of pediatric interfacility-transport with extracorporeal membrane oxygenation (ECMO) in China. Methods: The data of 48 patients transported inter-hospital from February 2016 to May 2018 were collected from the following 4 centers: pediatric intensive care unit (PICU) of Bayi Children's Hospital Affiliated to the 7th Medical Center of PLA General Hospital, Pediatric Hospital of Fudan University, Henan Provincial People's Hospital and Children's Hospital of Zhejiang University School of Medicine. The data of patients' characteristics, ECMO mode and wean rate, and mortality were reviewed, which was further compared with the data of 57 compatible inner-hospital ECMO cases with t test, Rank sum test or chi-square test. Results: All the 48 interfacility-transports were accomplished by ambulance on land, with an average transfer distance of (435±422) km. The incidence of ECMO complications was 13% (6 case), without death. There were no significant differences in lactic acid, PaO(2) or SaO(2) before and after transport (4.0 (2.0, 7.5) vs. 3.0 (1.5, 6.0) mmol/L, Z=-1.579, P>0.05; 112(47, 405) vs. 166(122, 240) mmHg (1 mmHg=0.133 kPa), Z=-0.104, P>0.05; 0.97±0.02 vs. 0.96±0.03, t=1.570, P>0.05). Instead, PaCO(2) and pH were significantly different ((47±8) vs. (42±5) mmHg, t=2.687, P<0.05; 7.3±0.2 vs. 7.5±0.2, t=3.379, P<0.05). The total ECMO weaned rate was 73% (35/48) and the survival rate was 67% (32/48). No significant differences in demographic characteristics, ECMO mode or duration, transport distance or duration, or complications existed between the survival group and the death group (7/25 vs. 2/14, χ(2)=0.615, P>0.05; 4/28 vs. 2/14, χ(2)=0, P>0.05; (405±404) vs. (493±465) km, t=0.525, P>0.05; (5±4) vs. (5±5) h, t=0.388, P>0.05; 166 (128, 239) vs. 187(52, 405) h, Z=-0.104, P>0.05; 3/32 vs. 3/16, χ(2)=0.734, P>0.05). The lowest lactate value in survival group before ECMO transport was significantly lower than that in the death group ((5±5) vs. (8±6) mmol/L, t=2.151, P<0.05). There were neither significant differences in age, ECMO mode or support pattern (9/39 vs. 15/42, χ(2)=0.845, P>0.05; 6/42 vs. 7/50, χ(2)=0.001, P>0.05; 29/19 vs. 38/19, χ(2)=0.441, P>0.05), nor in ECMO weaned rate, survival rate or complications between interfacility-transport group and inner-hospital group (35/48 vs. 37/57, χ(2)=0.775, P>0.05; 32/48 vs. 35/57, χ(2)=0.313, P>0.05; 20/48 vs. 22/57, χ(2)=0.102, P>0.05). Conclusion: With appropriate transport equipment and mature teams who handle problems timely during the transport, critically ill children could be safely transported to the destination with ECMO.
目的:介绍中国大陆儿科体外膜肺氧合(ECMO)转运现状并探讨其安全性。 方法:回顾性分析2016年2月至2018年5月,解放军总医院第七医学中心附属八一儿童医院、复旦大学附属儿科医院、河南省人民医院、浙江大学医学院附属儿童医院4个ECMO团队转运的48例患儿(ECMO转运组)的基本信息、ECMO支持模型、撤机率、成活率等病例资料,并与同期院内接受ECMO支持的57例患儿(院内组)进行比较,组间比较采用t检验、秩和检验或χ(2)检验。 结果:4家医院共完成了48例儿科重症ECMO转运,全部为陆地救护车转运,转运距离为(435±422)km,患儿ECMO转运途中并发症发生率为13%(6例),无转运途中死亡病例。转运前后患儿的乳酸、动脉血氧分压(PaO(2))、动脉血血氧饱和度(SaO(2))差异均无统计学意义[4.0(2.0,7.5)比3.0(1.5,6.0)mmol/L,Z=-1.579,P>0.05;112(47,405)比166(122,240)mmHg(1 mmHg=0.133 kPa),Z=-0.104,P>0.05;0.97±0.02比0.96±0.03,t=1.570,P>0.05],转运前后患儿动脉血二氧化碳分压(PaCO(2))、pH差异有统计学意义[(47±8)比(42±5)mmHg,t=2.687,P<0.05;7.3±0.2比7.5±0.2,t=3.379,P<0.05]。48例儿科ECMO转运病例中总撤机率73%(35例),存活率67%(32例)。转运存活组和转运死亡组的人群构成(新生儿/非新生儿)、ECMO支持模式(静脉-静脉模式/静脉-动脉模式)、转运距离、转运时间、ECMO支持时间、并发症发生率差异均无统计学意义[7/25比2/14,χ(2)=0.615,P>0.05;4/28比2/14,χ(2)=0,P>0.05;(405±404)比(493±465)km,t=0.525,P>0.05;(5±4)比(5±5)h,t=0.388,P>0.05;166(128,239)比187(52,405)h,Z=-0.104,P>0.05;3/32比3/16,χ(2)=0.734,P>0.05]。存活组ECMO转运前最高乳酸值显著低于死亡组[(5±5)比(8±6)mmol/L,t=2.151,P<0.05]。48例儿科ECMO转运组与同期57例儿科ECMO院内组进行比较,两组患儿的人群构成(新生儿/非新生儿)、支持模式(静脉-静脉模式/静脉-动脉模式)、支持类型(呼吸支持/心脏支持)差异均无统计学意义(9/39比15/42,χ(2)=0.845,P>0.05;6/42比7/50,χ(2)=0.001,P>0.05;29/19比38/19,χ(2)=0.441,P>0.05)。ECMO转运组和院内组患儿撤机率、存活率、并发症发生率差异均无统计学意义(35/48比37/57,χ(2)=0.775,P>0.05;32/48比35/57,χ(2)=0.313,P>0.05;20/48比22/57,χ(2)=0.102,P>0.05)。 结论:通过合适的转运设施、熟练的转运团队、及时处理转运途中出现问题,可以把危重患儿经ECMO安全转运至目的地。.
Keywords: Critical illness; Extracorporeal membrane oxygenation; Multicenter study.