The Kidney Donor Profile Index (KDPI) was introduced in the United States in 2014 to guide the decision making of clinicians with respect to accepting or declining a donated kidney. To evaluate whether the KDPI can be applied to a European cohort, we retrospectively assessed 580 adult patients who underwent renal transplantation (brain-dead donors) between January 2007 and December 2014 at our center and compared their KDPIs with their short- and long-term outcomes. This led to the observation of two associations: one between the KDPI and the estimated glomerular filtration rate at one year (1-y-eGFR) and the other between the KDPI and the death-censored allograft survival rate (both p < 0.001). Following this, the individual input factors of the KDPI were analyzed to assess their potential to evaluate the quality of a donor organ. We found that a donor's age alone is significantly predictive in terms of 1-y-eGFR and death-censored allograft survival (both p < 0.001). Therefore, a donor's age may serve as a simple reference for future graft function. Furthermore, we found that an organ with a low KDPI or from a young donor has an improved graft survival rate whereas kidneys with a high KDPI or from an older donor yield an inferior performance, but they are still acceptable. Therefore, we would not encourage defining a distinct KDPI cut-off in the decision-making process of accepting or declining a kidney graft.