Postoperative pain managed with opioids has contributed to the opioid crisis through overprescribing practices. We assessed opioid-prescribing habits and their use by patients undergoing surgery for cutaneous malignancies. An Institutional Review Board-approved retrospective analysis was conducted for patients who underwent skin cancer resection between January 2018 and June 2018. Data were collected from the electronic medical record, and opioid-related data were collected from patient interviews and state registries. There were 120 study participants (42 females and 78 males) with a median age of 67 years (range, 21-94 years). All received preincision local anesthetic: 64 had liposomal bupivacaine (LB) (53%) and 56 had non-LB bupivacaine (47%). Most participants (n = 88) used 0 opioids (73%), including 43 LB-anesthetic (67%) and 45 non-LB-anesthetic (80%). No significance was seen between those with a diagnosis of chronic pain, narcotic tolerance, an area of resection, and nodal sampling groups in opioid use. Four patients (3%) requested a refill. Of 105 prescriptions written for opioids, 99 had leftover opioids for an overprescribing rate of 94 per cent. This study suggests pain after skin cancer surgery is manageable with very limited opioid requirements. Our results support prescribing no more than five opioid tablets for postoperative pain control in patients undergoing resection for skin malignancies.