Performance of Pediatric Systemic Inflammatory Response Syndrome and Organ Dysfunction Criteria in Late-Onset Sepsis in a Quaternary Neonatal Intensive Care Unit: A Case-Control Study

Objectives: To evaluate accuracy of systemic inflammatory response syndrome (SIRS) criteria in identifying culture-proven late-onset neonatal sepsis and to assess prevalence of organ dysfunction and its relationship with SIRS criteria.

Study design: This was a retrospective case-control study of patients in the Children's Hospital of Philadelphia level IV neonatal intensive care unit undergoing sepsis evaluations (concurrent blood culture and antibiotics). During calendar years 2016-2017, 77 case and 77 control sepsis evaluations were identified. Cases included infants who had sepsis evaluations with positive blood cultures and antibiotic duration ≥7 days. Controls were matched by gestational and postmenstrual age, and had sepsis evaluations with negative blood cultures and antibiotic duration ≤48 hours. SIRS criteria were determined at time of sepsis evaluation, and organ dysfunction evaluated in the 72 hours following sepsis evaluation. Statistical analysis included descriptive statistics, Mann-Whitney tests, and χ² (Fisher exact) tests.

Results: At time of sepsis evaluation, 42% of cases and 26% of controls met SIRS criteria. Among infants of ≤37 weeks postmenstrual age, SIRS criteria were met in only 17% of sepsis evaluations (4 of 23 in both cases and controls). Test characteristics for SIRS at diagnosis of culture-proven sepsis included sensitivity 42% and specificity 74%. Cases had higher rates of new organ dysfunction within 72 hours (40% vs 21%); however, 58% of cases developing organ dysfunction did not meet SIRS criteria at time of sepsis evaluation. Of 6 deaths (all cases with organ dysfunction), 2 did not meet SIRS criteria at sepsis evaluation.

Conclusions: SIRS criteria did not accurately identify culture-proven late-onset sepsis, with poorest accuracy in preterm infants. SIRS criteria did not predict later organ dysfunction or mortality.