In this study, we investigate how the length of amphiphilic β-sheet forming peptides affects their interaction with membranes. Four polycationic model peptides with lengths from 6 to 18 amino acids were constructed from simple Lys-Leu repeats, giving [KL]n=3,5,7,9. We found that (1) they exhibit a pronounced antimicrobial activity with an intriguing length dependent maximum for [KL]5 with 10 amino acids; (2) their hemolytic effect, on the other hand, increases steadily with peptide length. CD analysis (3) and TEM (4) show that all peptides-except for the short [KL]3-aggregate into amyloid-like fibrils in the presence of phosphate ions, which in turn has a critical effect on the results in (1) and (2). In fact, (5) vesicle leakage reveals an intrinsic membrane-perturbing activity (at constant peptide mass) of [KL]5 > [KL]9 > [KL]7 in phosphate buffer, which changes to [KL]5 ≈ [KL]7 ≈ [KL]9 in PIPES. A specific interaction with phosphate ions thus explains the subtle balance between two counteracting effects: phosphate-induced unproductive pre-aggregation in solution versus monomeric membrane binding and vigorous lipid perturbation due to self-assembly of the bound peptides within the bilayer. This knowledge can now be used to control and optimize the peptides in further applications.