The challenge of using the virtual crossmatch as a singular tool for the detection of Anti-HLA antibodies- A study from a tertiary care institute from South India

Introduction: Detection of donor specific antibodies (DSA) is critical in both solid organ and mismatched haematopoietic stem cell transplants. The single antigen bead assay (SAB) is widely used as a virtual crossmatch in these settings. However, HLA allele variation across ethnicities and differing genetic backgrounds is a well-known and acknowledged fact and representation of alleles prevalent in a population is key while using a virtual crossmatch as a sole decision making tool. Against this background, this study was performed to assess the feasibility of using the SAB as a single tool to identify DSA in our population.

Materials and methods: The HLA alleles identified in the study population were analysed to assess their representation on SAB panels from two different vendors.

Results: The study population comprised of a total of 966 subjects for whom 6 loci high resolution HLA typing was done. A total of 241 different alleles were assigned in the population. Among the 241 alleles identified in our study population, 48.55% (n = 117) alleles were represented in the SAB A panel and 48.13% (n = 116) represented in the SAB B panel. Unrepresented alleles were 51.45% (n = 124) in panel A and 51.87% (n = 125) in panel B. All the twelve alleles were represented for 16.05% (n = 155) and 16.25% (n = 157) of study population in panel A and in panel B respectively. The remaining individuals (83.95%, (n = 811) in panel A and 83.75%, (n = 809) in panel B) had at least one allele unrepresented.

Conclusion: Our study addresses an important limitation in utilizing the SAB as a single tool to identify DSA, owing to non-representation of locally prevalent / unique alleles in our population. More than 50% of alleles were unrepresented in both the SAB assays we studied, which included alleles from both Class I and Class II. We recommend therefore that, until a comprehensive coverage of alleles is provided, or epitope matching becomes robust, that the SAB be combined with a physical crossmatch when mismatched alleles are not represented.