Establishing standardized methods for a consistent analysis of spectral data remains a largely underexplored aspect in surface-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (SERS), particularly applied to biological and biomedical research. Here we propose an effective machine learning classification of protein species with closely resembled spectral profiles by a mixed data processing based on principal component analysis (PCA) applied to multipeak fitting on SERS spectra. This strategy simultaneously assures a successful discrimination of proteins and a thorough characterization of the chemostructural differences among them, ultimately opening up new routes for SERS evolution toward sensing applications and diagnostics of interest in life sciences.