Acenocoumarol and phenprocoumon are vitamin K antagonists (VKA) with average half-lives of 11 hours and 160 hours, respectively. They are used to treat and prevent thrombosis in mechanical cardiac valve replacement, atrial fibrillation and venous thromboembolism. There are historical regional differences in preferred VKA in the Netherlands. Safe and effective treatment requires the international normalized ratios (INRs) to be in the therapeutic range, and stable. Theoretically, the longer-acting phenprocoumon would yield a higher time in therapeutic range (TTR) and lower INR variability. In practice, switching from acenocoumarol to phenprocoumon eventually improves INR variability and in some patients TTR as well. However, during the preceding transition period, INRs are more often volatile and supratherapeutic. Furthermore, switching to an alternative VKA could weaken integrated care, as other healthcare providers are less experienced with it. Healthcare providers must coordinate an intended switch with the anticoagulation clinic.