A population-level statistic for assessing Mendelian behavior of genotyping-by-sequencing data from highly duplicated genomes

Background: Given the economic and environmental importance of allopolyploids and other species with highly duplicated genomes, there is a need for methods to distinguish paralogs, i.e. duplicate sequences within a genome, from Mendelian loci, i.e. single copy sequences that pair at meiosis. The ratio of observed to expected heterozygosity is an effective tool for filtering loci but requires genotyping to be performed first at a high computational cost, whereas counting the number of sequence tags detected per genotype is computationally quick but very ineffective in inbred or polyploid populations. Therefore, new methods are needed for filtering paralogs.

Results: We introduce a novel statistic, H_ind/H_E, that uses the probability that two reads sampled from a genotype will belong to different alleles, instead of observed heterozygosity. The expected value of H_ind/H_E is the same across all loci in a dataset, regardless of read depth or allele frequency. In contrast to methods based on observed heterozygosity, it can be estimated and used for filtering loci prior to genotype calling. In addition to filtering paralogs, it can be used to filter loci with null alleles or high overdispersion, and identify individuals with unexpected ploidy and hybrid status. We demonstrate that the statistic is useful at read depths as low as five to 10, well below the depth needed for accurate genotype calling in polyploid and outcrossing species.

Conclusions: Our methodology for estimating H_ind/H_E across loci and individuals, as well as determining reasonable thresholds for filtering loci, is implemented in polyRAD v1.6, available at https://github.com/lvclark/polyRAD . In large sequencing datasets, we anticipate that the ability to filter markers and identify problematic individuals prior to genotype calling will save researchers considerable computational time.