What Proportion of Active-duty Servicemembers Functionally Improve at 1 Year Post Hallux Valgus Correction?

Background: When the symptoms of hallux valgus persist despite nonoperative management, surgical intervention may be considered to improve pain and restore function. Although most patients return to full or near-full activity after surgery, this is not always the case in higher-demand populations. In fact, little is known about the likelihood of a military servicemember returning to running or military duty, which is analogous to a recreationally active adult, after hallux valgus correction.

Questions/purposes: (1) What percentage of military servicemembers are able to return to full duty, including the ability to run 1.5 to 2 miles, 1 year after hallux valgus surgery? (2) What demographic, radiographic, and surgical variables are associated with an increased likelihood of return to full duty?

Methods: This was a retrospective study of all military servicemembers who underwent surgical correction of hallux valgus deformities at a single tertiary institution from January 2005 to December 2016. We considered military servicemembers who were treated by four fellowship-trained foot and ankle orthopaedic surgeons and who had at least 1 year time-in-service remaining as potentially eligible. A total of 229 people underwent hallux valgus correction during this timeframe, but only 28% (64 of 229) of patients remained eligible: 41% (93 of 229) were excluded because they were not military members, 28% (64 of 229) were ineligible because they had less than 1 year remaining in service, 2% (4 of 229) were excluded because of prior surgery on the ipsilateral extremity, and 2% (4 of 2292) had an incomplete dataset. Interventions included a modified McBride procedure (9% [6 of 64]), distal metatarsal osteotomies (51% [33 of 64]), proximal metatarsal osteotomies (13% [8 of 64]), and Lapidus procedures (27% [17 of 64]). No bilateral procedures were performed. The mean age of our patients was 40 ± 10 years, and the mean BMI was 28 ± 9 kg/m 2 . In addition, 23% (15 of 64) of patients were nicotine users, 38% (24 of 64) were officers, and 45% (29 of 64) were women. The indication for surgery was functionally limiting pain that persisted despite 4 to 6 months of activity modifications, accommodative footwear, and orthotics. Cosmesis was not an indication for surgery. Before surgery, all patients were unable to complete a 1.5- to 2-mile timed run due to pain. The primary outcome measure was the proportion of patients who returned to full duty, which was defined as the ability to complete a 1.5-mile to 2-mile run for a military fitness test in a fixed time allotment, which varies by age and gender, and the ability to perform military-specific physical tasks at 1 year postoperatively. A secondary analysis according to demographic, radiographic, and surgical variables sought to determine any differences between those who did and did not return to full duty; this was assessed using univariable statistical comparisons at a p value of less than 0.01.

Results: A total of 28% (18 of 64) of patients who underwent surgery returned to full duty by 1 year after surgery as determined by the ability to complete a time-allotted 1.5- to 2-mile fitness test run. Of the factors we explored, we did not identify any variables associated with return to full duty. We note that our analysis may have been underpowered to detect differences among factors that could be clinically important, like BMI, age, and comparisons of officers versus enlisted servicemembers.

Conclusion: Although this study analyzed the functional outcomes of a group of military servicemembers after hallux valgus correction, we believe our findings may also apply to recreationally active adults in the general population. Only a minority of military servicemembers (28% [18 of 64]) returned to duty 1 year after hallux valgus correction, as determined by the ability to complete a timed 1.5- to 2-mile run. We believe surgeons can use the findings of this study to set realistic expectations for recreationally active adults, particularly runners, after hallux valgus correction.

Level of evidence: Level III, therapeutic study.