Papillary renal neoplasm with reverse polarity with a favorable prognosis should be separated from papillary renal cell carcinoma

Papillary renal neoplasm with reverse polarity (PRNRP) is a newly documented renal entity with an easily recognizable morphology, distinct immunohistochemical profiles, and frequent KRAS mutations. The latest practice guidelines regard PRNRP as a subtype of papillary renal cell carcinoma due to the documented chromosomal alterations of 7, 17, and Y. This study included 20 patients with PRNRP and 30 patients with PRCC. Statistically significant differences were observed in size, WHO/ISUP grade, macrophages in the papillae, reverse polarity, CK7, basolateral positivity for Claudin7, GATA3 expression, KRAS mutation, and chromosomal alterations. No adverse events such as perinephric invasion, lymphovascular invasion, sarcomatoid of rhabdoid differentiation, metastasis, or recurrence were found in PRNRP. However, PRCC can cause these adverse events. Basolateral positivity for Claudin7 together with GATA3 expression indicated distal tubule derivation of PRNRP. KRAS mutations were detected in 89% (16/18) of PRNRP. No KRAS mutations were detected in PRCC. Six patients with PRNRP had one chromosomal alteration and the other 12 had no chromosomal alterations. However, only four patients with PRCC showed no chromosomal alterations. Eighteen patients had two or three chromosomal alterations. PRCC can metastasize, recur, and even cause death, whereas PRNRP has a favorable prognosis. We recommend that PRNRP should be separated from PRCC and partial nephrectomy is more suitable for PRNRP.