Two new complementary Au(I)-catalyzed methods for the preparation of ester-substituted indolizines from easily accessible 2-propargyloxypyridines and either acetoacetates or dimethyl malonate are reported. These reactions tolerate a wide range of functionality, allowing for diversification at three distinct positions of the product (R, R1, R2). For electron-poor substrates, the highest yields are observed upon reaction with acetoacetates, while neutral and electron-rich substrates give higher yields upon treatment with dimethyl malonate.