Cyclin-dependent kinases (CDKs) are key mediators of cell proliferation and have been a subject of oncology drug discovery efforts for over two decades. Several CDK and activator cyclin family members have been implicated in regulating the cell division cycle. While it is thought that there are canonical CDK-cyclin pairing preferences, the extent of selectivity is unclear, and increasing evidence suggests that the cell-cycle CDKs can be activated by a pool of available cyclins. The molecular details of CDK-cyclin specificity are not completely understood despite their importance for understanding cancer cell cycles and for pharmacological inhibition of cancer proliferation. We report here a biolayer interferometry assay that allows for facile quantification of CDK binding interactions with their cyclin activators. We applied this assay to measure the impact of Cdk2 inhibitors on Cyclin A (CycA) association and dissociation kinetics. We found that Type I inhibitors increase the affinity between Cdk2 and CycA by virtue of a slowed cyclin dissociation rate. In contrast, Type II inhibitors and other small-molecule Cdk2 binders have distinct effects on the CycA association and dissociation processes to decrease affinity. We propose that the differential impact of small molecules on the cyclin binding kinetics arises from the plasticity of the Cdk2 active site as the kinase transitions between active, intermediate, and inactive states.