Confronting historical legacies of biological anthropology in South Africa-Restitution, redress and community-centered science: The Sutherland Nine

PLoS One. 2023 May 24;18(5):e0284785. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0284785. eCollection 2023.

Abstract

We describe a process of restitution of nine unethically acquired human skeletons to their families, together with attempts at redress. Between 1925-1927 C.E., the skeletonised remains of nine San or Khoekhoe people, eight of them known-in-life, were removed from their graves on the farm Kruisrivier, near Sutherland in the Northern Cape Province of South Africa. They were donated to the Anatomy Department at the University of Cape Town. This was done without the knowledge or permission of their families. The donor was a medical student who removed the remains from the labourers' cemetery on his family farm. Nearly 100 years later, the remains are being returned to their community, accompanied by a range of community-driven interdisciplinary historical, archaeological and analytical (osteobiographic, craniofacial, ancient DNA, stable isotope) studies to document, as far as possible, their lives and deaths. The restitution process began by contacting families living in the same area with the same surnames as the deceased. The restitution and redress process prioritises the descendant families' memories, wishes and desire to understand the situation, and learn more about their ancestors. The descendant families have described the process as helping them to reconnect with their ancestors. A richer appreciation of their ancestors' lives, gained in part from scientific analyses, culminating with reburial, is hoped to aid the descendant families and wider community in [re-]connecting with their heritage and culture, and contribute to restorative justice, reconciliation and healing while confronting a traumatic historical moment. While these nine individuals were exhumed as specimens, they will be reburied as people.

Publication types

  • Research Support, Non-U.S. Gov't

MeSH terms

  • Anthropology*
  • Archaeology*
  • Cemeteries
  • DNA, Ancient
  • Humans
  • South Africa

Substances

  • DNA, Ancient

Grants and funding

The following funders are acknowledged: The public participation process and the ZAMANI project mapping of the Kruisrivier cemetery were supported by UCT. Osteobiographic research was supported through the National Research Foundation, South Africa (Grant No. 115357 and 120816), the Department of Human Biology, UCT, and Gibbon’s internal research grant. Funding for CT scans was provided by the Medical Imaging Research Unit within the Division of Biomedical Engineering, UCT. Facial reconstruction and depiction were supported through a National Geographic Society Explorer grant (EC-60001R-19) Liverpool John Moores University QR fund and UCT. Ancient DNA analyses were funded by the Max Planck Society, Germany. Stable isotope research was funded by the South African Research Chairs Initiative (Grant No. 84407), and the Biogeochemistry Research Infrastructure Platform, supported by the Department of Science and Innovation of South Africa. Opinions expressed and conclusions arrived at are those of the authors and not necessarily to be attributed to the National Research Foundation.