Implications of Tumor Surgery in Horseshoe Kidneys: A Comparative Study of Outcomes and Surgical Practices

Objective: To contrast surgical outcomes of Horseshoe Kidney (HSK) patients with localized renal masses suspected of cancer with nonfused nonectopic kidney patients, emphasizing safe surgical practices for HSKs.

Methods: The study examined solid tumors from the Mayo Clinic Nephrectomy registry between 1971 and 2021. Each HSK case was matched to three non-HSK patients based on various factors. The outcomes measured included complications within 30days of surgery, change in estimated glomerular filtration rate, and overall, cancer-specific, and metastasis-free survival rates.

Results: Thirty of the 34 HSKs had malignant tumors compared with 90 of the 102 patients in the nonfused nonectopic referent cohort. Accessory isthmus arteries were present in 93% of HSK cases, with 43% exhibiting multiple arteries and 7% with 6 or more arteries. Estimated blood loss and surgery duration were significantly higher in HSKs (900 vs 300 mL, P = .004; 246 vs 163 minutes, P < .001, respectively). The HSK group demonstrated an overall complication rate of 26% (vs 17% in referents, P = .2) and a median change in estimated glomerular filtration rate at 3months of - 8.5 (vs -8.1 in referents, P = .8). At 5-year follow-up, survival rates for HSK patients were 72%, 91%, and 69% for overall, cancer-specific, and metastasis-free survival, respectively. The corresponding rates were 79%, 86%, and 77%, respectively, for matched referent patients (P > .05).

Conclusion: HSK tumor management is technically challenging with higher blood loss; however, the data demonstrate comparable outcomes for patients with HSK tumors, including complications and survival, to those without HSKs in experienced centers.