Efficacy of algaecides for the proactive treatment of overwintering cyanobacteria

Once established within a water resource, harmful algal blooms (HABs) can occur seasonally with an intense and rapid onset, giving water resource managers limited time to respond to lessen risks. An attractive strategy to decrease human, ecological, and economic risks from HABs is to implement proactive algaecide treatments applied to overwintering cyanobacteria (i.e., akinetes and quiescent vegetative cells) in sediments prior to the formation of a HAB; however, this approach is novel and very limited efficacy data exist. Therefore, the specific objectives of this research were to 1) evaluate copper- and peroxide-based algaecides, applied as single and repeat treatments at the bench scale, to identify effective proactive treatments, and 2) compare correlations between cell density and other response measurements (i.e., in vivo chlorophyll a and phycocyanin concentrations and percent benthic coverage), to identify informative metrics to assess overwintering cyanobacteria responses. Twelve treatment scenarios using copper- and peroxide-based algaecides were applied to sediments containing overwintering cyanobacteria prior to a 14 d incubation under favorable growth conditions. Responses of cyanobacteria in the planktonic (i.e., cell density, in vivo chlorophyll a and phycocyanin concentrations) and benthic (percent coverage) phases after a 14 d incubation were evaluated in treatments and controls. The HAB-forming cyanobacteria present after a 14 d incubation were: Aphanizomenon, Dolichospermum, Microcystis, Nostoc, and Planktonthrix. Successive treatments of copper sulfate (CuSulfate) followed by sodium carbonate peroxyhydrate (PeroxiSolid) (second algaecide applied after 24 h) as well as repeat applications of a single algaecide, PeroxiSolid (second treatment applied after 24 h) resulted in statistically significant (p ≤ 0.05; α = 0.05) declines in cell density relative to untreated controls. Planktonic cyanobacteria responses measured in terms of phycocyanin concentrations were strongly correlated with cyanobacteria density measurements (Pearson's correlation coefficient (r) = 0.89). Chlorophyll a concentrations and percent benthic coverage did not correlate with planktonic cyanobacteria density measurements (r = 0.37 and -0.49, respectively) and therefore, were unreliable metrics for cyanobacterial responses in this study. These data provide initial evidence of the efficacy of algaecides for treating overwintering cells in sediments and contribute to our overarching hypothesis that proactive treatments may delay the onset and intensity of HABs in impacted waterbodies.