Effects of the number of competing responses on neural signatures of pre- and post-response conflict

The optimization of human performance requires the continuous monitoring of behavioral conflicts. According to conflict monitoring theory, the dorsal anterior cingulate cortex registers response conflict which is reflected by two electrophysiological signatures, the N2 and the Ne/ERN. The theory assumes that, if a stimulus activates an incorrect response that competes with the correct response, pre-response conflict on correct trials (reflected by the N2) is enhanced but post-response conflict on error trials (reflected by the Ne/ERN) is reduced. Here, we asked whether response conflict depends on the number of competing incorrect responses activated by a stimulus, that is, whether the N2 is further enhanced and the Ne/ERN is further reduced if two incorrect responses are activated as compared to one. To this end, we used a modified flanker paradigm, in which the two flankers were associated either with the same incorrect response or with different incorrect responses. Our results indicate an increased N2 on correct trials and a reduced Ne/ERN on error trials in the latter as compared to the former condition. These results confirm central predictions of conflict monitoring theory and demonstrate that response conflict is directly related to the number of competing incorrect responses.