Are T2WI PI-RADS sub-scores of transition zone prostate lesions biased by DWI information? A multi-reader, single-center study

Purpose: According to PI-RADS v2.1, T2-weighted imaging (T2WI) is the dominant sequence for transition zone (TZ) lesions. This study aimed to assess, whether diffusion-weighted imaging (DWI) information influences the assignment of T2WI scores.

Method: Out of 283 prostate MRI examinations with correlated biopsy results, fourty-four patients were selected retrospectively: first, 22 patients with a TZ lesion with T2WI and DWI scores ≥ 4, to represent lesions with unequivocal suspicion on T2WI and DWI. Second, 22 additional patients with TZ lesions of similar T2WI appearance but with corresponding DWI score ≤ 3 were added as control. Four residents and one board-certified radiologist each performed two assessments of the included patients: First, only T2WI was available (T2-only read); second, both T2WI and DWI sequences were available (biparametric read). Lesion scores were assessed using Wilcoxon signed-rank test, inter-reader agreement using weighted kappa and Kendall's W statistics, and sensitivity/specificity using McNemar test.

Results: The T2WI scores were significantly different between the T2-only and biparametric read for 3 out of 4 residents (p ≤ 0.049) but not for the radiologist. The overall PI-RADS scores derived from the two reading sessions differed considerably for 35/220 cases (all readers pooled). Inter-reader agreement was fair for the T2WI and overall PI-RADS scores (mean kappa 0.27-0.30) and moderate for the DWI scores (mean kappa 0.43).

Conclusions: For inexperienced readers, assessment of T2WI is variable and potentially biased by availability of DWI information, which can lead to changes of overall PI-RADS score and consequently clinical management. Assessment of T2WI should be performed before reviewing DWI to ensure non-biased interpretation of TZ lesions in the dominant sequence.