Risk Factor Profile in Inpatients with School Refusal: a Dimensional Model

Background: School attendance problems have an impact on the social, academic, and professional development of young people. School refusal and truancy are described as school attendance problems. Clarifying the developmental trajectory of school refusal would allow a better understanding of the phenomenon including earlier detection and improved management. Following a dimensional model, we can consider school refusal as an internalizing problem and truancy as an externalizing problem implying the existence of different risk factor profiles.

Subject and method: We conducted a retrospective study on four groups of child and adolescent inpatients (school refusal (SR), truancy (TR), behavior disorder without deschooling (BD), and eating disorder (ED). Each subject was included in one of the groups based on a checklist criterion and the diagnoses made at the end of hospitalization. We then compared groups with descriptive statistics (Chi^² and Fisher's exact test) to highlight the developmental trajectory and the possible risk factors profile in SR.

Results: Delayed language development, attachment disorder, attentional deficit and hyperactivity disorder, physical abuse, and substance abuse were predominantly reported in BD and TR. Learning disorders were mostly present in BD, TR, and SR. Family interactions were more violent and aggressive in BD and TR than in ED and SR. We observed more violent and conflictual relationships with peers in BD and TR. In SR, subjects seemed to experiment with more isolation and rejection. Behavioral disorder non-specified, ODD, and CD seemed more frequent in BD and TR. We found anxiety disorder and mood disorders more frequently in the SR group.

Conclusion: Inpatients with severe SR are characterized by internalizing problems and difficulties in emotional dysregulation and problems socializing with peers. Inpatients with BD and TR were associated with externalizing problems and difficulties in behavioral regulation skills.