[Clinical characteristics and efficacy of vocal fold epidermoid cysts coexisting with sulcus vocalis]

Zhonghua Er Bi Yan Hou Tou Jing Wai Ke Za Zhi. 2024 Mar 7;59(3):219-226. doi: 10.3760/cma.j.cn115330-20231122-00235.
[Article in Chinese]

Abstract

Objective: To investigate the clinical characteristics and voice outcomes after laryngeal microsurgery for vocal fold epidermoid cysts coexisting with sulcus vocalis. Methods: The clinical data of 115 vocal fold epidermoid cysts coexisting with sulcus vocalis patients in Shandong provincial ENT hospital, were retrospectively analyzed, including 49 males and 66 females, aged 17-70 years old, and the duration of hoarseness ranged from 6 months to 30 years. All patients underwent surgery through suspension laryngoscope and microscope under general anestgesia. Ninety-four patients were treated with microflap excision of sulcus vocalis, cyst wall, and contents.And 21 patients that occulted with mucosal bridges were applied mucosal bridges resection (2 cases) and mucosal bridges reconstruction (19 cases) respectively. Videolaryngoscopy, subjective voice evaluation (GRBAS), objective voice evaluation, and Voice Handicap Index(VHI) were performed before and after surgery. All patients underwent histopathologic examination and follow-up after the procedure. The preoperative acoustic parameters of patients with vocal fold epidermoid cysts coexisting with sulcus vocalis were compared with those of vocal fold mucus retention cysts and simple vocal fold epidermoid cysts by independent samples t-test. The patients were compared by paired t-test for preoperative and postoperative parameters. Results: Significant reduction or lack of mucosal waves were shown via videolaryngostroboscopy in all 115 cases.In addition, vascular changes including dilation, tortuousness, increased branches, and abrupt direction change were shown on the cystic area. Eighty-one patients were detected cysts and/or sulcus vocalis by preoperative laryngoscopy, and intraoperative microscopic findings in the remaining 34 patients. The intraoperative microscopic examination revealed a focal pouch-like deficit plunging into the vocal ligament or muscle. The deep surface of the mucosal bridges was sulcus vocalis, and that in 89 cysts was lined with caseous content. Histopathology demonstrated a cystic cavity structure lined with squamous epithelium and caseous keratin desquamation inside the cystic cavity. Four of 115 patients were lost at follow-up and excluded from the analysis of voice outcomes after surgery. There was no significant mucosal wave and the voice quality in all but 14 patients 1month after surgery. Except for the fundamental frequency and noise harmonic ratio, all other voice parameters[ G, R, B, A, VHI-10, jitter, shimmer, maximum phonatory time (MPT) ]showed a significant improvement 3 months after surgery(t=15.82, 20.82, 17.61, 7.30, 38.88, 7.84, 5.88, -6.26, respectively, P<0.05). Then mucosal waves and the voice quality were gradually improved and became steady in 6 months after surgery. The subjective and objective voice parameters[G, R, B, A, VHI-10, jitter, shimmer, noise to harmonic ratio(NHR), MPT], except for the fundamental frequency, were all significantly improved(t=23.47, 25.79, 18.37, 9.84, 54.45, 10.68, 8.07, 3.24, -9.08, respectively, P<0.05). In addition, there were 2 patients with no significant improvement after the operation. Steady function with no complications was observed during the 12 months (up to 3 years in 34 patients) follow-up period in 111 patients. Conclusion: Ruptured vocal fold epidermoid cysts can result in sulcus vocalis and mucosal bridges. Characteristics changes in preoperative videolaryngoscopy are effective diagnostic tools. The complete excision of the cyst wall and repair of the lamina propria can lead to satisfactory long-term effects.

目的: 探讨声带表皮样囊肿合并声带沟的临床特点及手术疗效。 方法: 该回顾性病例系列研究分析了2018年5月至2021年7月山东省耳鼻喉医院收治的115例声带表皮样囊肿合并声带沟患者的临床资料,其中49例男性,66例女性,年龄17~70(中位年龄45岁)岁,嗓音障碍病程6个月~30年。所有患者手术均于全身麻醉支撑喉镜及手术显微镜下进行。声带表皮样囊肿单开口合并声带沟者,行声带沟及残留囊壁剥离切除(94例);双开口合并黏膜桥患者,同时给予黏膜桥切除(2例)或黏膜桥整复重建(19例)。患者手术前、后均行喉镜检查,以及主观听感知评估(GRBAS评估)、客观嗓音评估、嗓音障碍指数(Voice Handicap Index,VHI)评估。术后均行组织病理学检查,常规随访。采用独立样本t检验比较分析声带表皮样囊肿合并声带沟患者与单纯声带表皮样囊肿(n=116)和黏液潴留型声带囊肿(n=169)的术前客观评估参数。采用配对样本t检验比较分析声带表皮样囊肿合并声带沟患者手术前后的主、客观评估参数。 结果: 115例声带表皮样囊肿合并声带沟患者术前动态喉镜均可见局部黏膜波明显减弱或消失,病变部位上表面黏膜血管扩张并走向异常。115例患者中,通过术前喉镜发现囊肿和/或声带沟者81例,术中显微镜下发现声带囊肿合并声带沟者34例。表皮样囊肿合并声带沟患者手术显微镜下可见局限性声带沟,沟基底即为囊袋,内陷入声韧带并与其粘连,21例合并黏膜桥者,黏膜桥深面即为声带沟,89例囊袋内可见囊液或干酪样角化物。病理检查结果发现,囊腔样结构,囊壁为内衬鳞状上皮,边缘与声带黏膜被覆鳞状上皮移行,其内可见角化物。4例患者失访,其余111例均纳入手术疗效评估。术后1个月时,除14例患者黏膜波及音质较术前改善外,其余患者均无明显黏膜波及音质恢复。与术前相比,患者术后3个月的主、客观嗓音评估(G、R、B、A、VHI-10、基频微扰、振幅微扰、最长发音时间)均显著提高(t值分别为15.82、20.82、17.61、7.30、38.88、7.84、5.88、-6.26,P值均<0.05);术后6个月的黏膜波及音质进一步提高并维持稳定,G、R、B、A、VHI-10、基频微扰、振幅微扰、噪谐比、最长发音时间均显著改善(t值分别为23.47、25.79、18.37、9.84、54.45、10.68、8.07、3.24、-9.08,P值均<0.05)。2例声带黏膜波及主客观评估均无明显改善。111例患者均随访至12个月及以上,其中34例患者随访满3年,随访期间患者主、客观嗓音指标稳定。 结论: 表皮样囊肿可开放形成声带沟或黏膜桥,嗓音障碍病史较长且病变隐匿,术前喉镜检查有助于诊断,完整剥离残留囊壁及整复固有层可获得满意疗效。.

Publication types

  • English Abstract

MeSH terms

  • Adolescent
  • Adult
  • Aged
  • Epidermal Cyst* / complications
  • Epidermal Cyst* / pathology
  • Epidermal Cyst* / surgery
  • Female
  • Humans
  • Laryngeal Diseases* / pathology
  • Laryngeal Diseases* / surgery
  • Male
  • Middle Aged
  • Retrospective Studies
  • Treatment Outcome
  • Vocal Cords / pathology
  • Voice Quality
  • Young Adult