Few weight loss and weight loss maintenance interventions are tailored to include factors demonstrated to predict the user's behavior. Establishing the feasibility and acceptability of such interventions is crucial. The aim of this study was to assess the acceptability and feasibility of a theory-based, tailored, online-delivered weight loss and weight loss maintenance intervention (Choosing Health). We conducted a mixed methods process evaluation of the Choosing Health tailored intervention, nested in a randomized controlled trial (N = 288) with an embedded N-of-1 study, investigating participants' and implementers' experiences related to intervention context, implementation, and mechanisms of impact. Measures included: (i) surveys, (ii) data-prompted interviews (DPIs) with study participants, (iii) semi-structured interviews with implementers, and (iv) intervention access and engagement data. Five themes described the acceptability of the intervention to participants: (i) monitoring behavior change and personal progress to better understand the weight management process, (ii) working collaboratively with the intervention implementers to achieve participants' goals, (iii) perceived benefits of non-judgmental and problem-solving tone of the intervention, (iv) changes in personal perception of the weight management process due to intervention tailoring, and (v) insufficient intervention content tailoring. The intervention delivery was feasible, however, emails and text messages differed in terms of accessibility and resources required to deliver the content. The use of Ecological Momentary Assessment as a technique to gather personal data for further tailoring was acceptable, and facilitated behavior change monitoring. Personalization of the intervention content above and beyond domain-specific issues, for example, by addressing participants' social roles may better match their needs. Support from the implementers and feedback on body composition changes may increase participants' engagement.
Keywords: digital health; ecological momentary assessment; obesity; overweight; process evaluation; weight loss.
People with overweight and obesity can benefit from participating in behavior change programs that are individually adjusted to participants’ psychological characteristics. It is important to provide knowledge of how to design acceptable and feasible, widely accessible, sustainable tailored interventions for weight loss, and weight loss maintenance. We designed Choosing Health—a tailored intervention that matched intervention content to psychological factors that were demonstrated to influence each participant’s behavior. This study assessed whether the Choosing Health program was acceptable and feasible from the point of view of program participants and people who worked directly with the participants. The intervention tailoring supported participants in changing the way they thought about the weight loss process, and regular tailored messages served as a cue to maintain healthy habits. However, tailoring based on psychological characteristics was insufficient for many participants, as they would have preferred more personalized content. We provide guidance on good practices to gather data for tailored support, monitor behavior change progress, and for communicating with participants, to improve the acceptability of tailored interventions. We also compare how acceptable participants found methods of intervention delivery (SMS messages, emails, handbook) to advise which methods are the most acceptable and preferred by participants.
© Society of Behavioral Medicine 2024. All rights reserved. For commercial re-use, please contact [email protected] for reprints and translation rights for reprints. All other permissions can be obtained through our RightsLink service via the Permissions link on the article page on our site—for further information please contact [email protected].