We have successfully created self-assembled membranes by combining positively charged (Pro-X-(Phe-X)5-Pro) PFX peptides with negatively charged alginate. These PFX/alginate membranes were formed by three different peptides that contain either X = Arginine (R), Histidine (H), or Ornithine (O) as their charged amino acid. The assemblies were compared to membranes that were previously reported by us composed of X = lysine (K). This study enabled us to elucidate the impact of amino acids' specific interactions on membrane formation. SEM, SAXS, and cryo-TEM measurements show that although K, R, H, and O may have a similar net charge, the specific traits of the charged amino acid is an essential factor in determining the hierarchical structure of alginate/PFX self-assembled membranes.