Nutritional convergence in plants growing on gypsum soils in two distinct climatic regions

Background and aims: Soil endemics have long fascinated botanists owing to the insights they can provide about plant ecology and evolution. Often, these species have unique foliar nutrient composition patterns that reflect potential physiological adaptations to these harsh soil types. However, understanding global nutritional patterns to unique soil types can be complicated by the influence of recent and ancient evolutionary events. Our goal was to understand whether plant specialization to unique soils is a stronger determinant of nutrient composition of plants than climate or evolutionary constraints.

Methods: We worked on gypsum soils. We analysed whole-plant nutrient composition (leaves, stems, coarse roots and fine roots) of 36 native species of gypsophilous lineages from the Chihuahuan Desert (North America) and the Iberian Peninsula (Europe) regions, including widely distributed gypsum endemics, as specialists, and narrowly distributed endemics and non-endemics, as non-specialists. We evaluated the impact of evolutionary events and soil composition on the whole-plant composition, comparing the three categories of gypsum plants.

Key results: Our findings reveal nutritional convergence of widely distributed gypsum endemics. These taxa displayed higher foliar sulphur and higher whole-plant magnesium than their non-endemic relatives, irrespective of geographical location or phylogenetic history. Sulphur and magnesium concentrations were mainly explained by non-phylogenetic variation among species related to gypsum specialization. Other nutrient concentrations were determined by more ancient evolutionary events. For example, Caryophyllales usually displayed high foliar calcium, whereas Poaceae did not. In contrast, plant concentrations of phosphorus were mainly explained by species-specific physiology not related to gypsum specialization or evolutionary constraints.

Conclusions: Plant specialization to a unique soil can strongly influence plant nutritional strategies, as we described for gypsophilous lineages. Taking a whole-plant perspective (all organs) within a phylogenetic framework has enabled us to gain a better understanding of plant adaptation to unique soils when studying taxa from distinct regions.