Utility of Clinical-Pathological Parameters for Exclusion of BRCA1/2 Mutation Carriers as Candidates for Partial Breast Irradiation

Purpose: Several international groups have published guidelines to identify low-risk breast cancer (BC) patients who are eligible for partial breast irradiation (PBI). These include the American Society for Radiation Oncology (ASTRO), the European Society for Radiotherapy and Oncology (ESTRO), and ESTRO subgroups such as the Intraoperative radiation (IORT) Task Force and Groupe Européen de Curiethérapie (GEC) -ESTRO. Only ASTRO guidelines recommend against the use of PBI in known carriers of germline pathogenic variants (PVs) in BRCA1/2. The aim of this study was to evaluate the proportion of BC patients, subsequently found to be BRCA1/2 PV carriers who would be eligible for PBI based on clinical-pathologic criteria of the above-mentioned international guidelines.

Methods and materials: Data were extracted from the medical records of consecutive BC BRCA1/2 PV carriers treated at a single institution between 2006 and 2023. Data included patient demographics, tumor characteristics, treatment, and disease outcomes.

Results: Overall, 498 patients with 518 primary tumors were analyzed. Of these, 282 (12 of them with synchronous bilateral disease) presented with unknown genetic status at diagnosis and formed the study cohort. The median age at diagnosis was 42.7 years (range, 23.8-77.9). Based on the recent ASTRO guidelines (not including conditionally recommended criteria), 17 of 294 (5.8%) of the carriers had tumors that would be eligible for PBI, including 3 Her2-positive tumors and 5 patients diagnosed between ages 40 and 49 years. Using the ESTRO IORT and the ACROP-ESTRO PBI criteria, 9 of 294 (3%) would be eligible, whereas with the GEC-ESTRO low-risk criteria, 31 of 294 (10.5%) of the carriers would be eligible, and their intermediate risk criteria would increase eligibility for PBI by an additional 8.2% (overall 18.7%).

Conclusions: Using clinical-pathologic criteria published in international guidelines, 3% to 18% of BRCA1/2 PV carriers will have tumors eligible for PBI. Therefore, especially in populations who are at high risk for being BRCA1/2 PV carriers, we recommend adhering to stricter guidelines. In our cohort, ASTRO, ESTRO-IORT, and ESTRO PBI had the lowest probability of identifying BRCA1/2 PV carriers as eligible for PBI.