Despite extensive research on the sequence-determined self-assembly of both pathogenic and nonpathogenic proteins, the question of how the sequence identity would influence the coassembly or cross-seeding of diverse proteins without distinct sequence similarity remains largely unanswered. Here, we demonstrate that the rapid coaggregation of proteins with negligible sequence similarity is fundamentally governed by preferred heteromeric interactions between their partially unfolded states via the gain of additional charge complementarity and hydrophobic interactions. The partial loss of intramolecular interactions and concurrent gain of non-native intrinsically disordered regions with sticky groups become crucial for both aggressive heteromeric primary nucleation and secondary nucleation events. The results signify the direct relevance of sequence-independent conformational cross-talk between diverse proteins to the foundational events required for the growth of biological multiprotein amyloid deposits.