BRCA loss of function including BRCA1 DNA-methylation, but not BRCA-unrelated homologous recombination deficiency, is associated with platinum hypersensitivity in high-grade ovarian cancer

Background: In high-grade ovarian cancer (HGOC), determination of homologous recombination deficiency (HRD) status is commonly used in routine practice to predict response to platinum-based therapy or poly (ADP-ribose) polymerase inhibitors (PARPi). Here we tested the hypothesis that BRCA loss of function (LOF) due to epigenetic or genetic aberrations is a better predictor for the clinical outcome than HRD. One hundred thirty-one HGOC tissues were tested for BRCA DNA-methylation, BRCA mutations, HRD and BRCA1 mRNA expression, followed by a comprehensive survival analysis.

Results: BRCA1-methylation was detected in 11% of the tumors, exclusively in BRCA1-wild-type (wt) HGOCs. BRCA1-methylated tumors (BRCA1-meth) had HRD-scores similar to those of BRCA-mutated (mut) tumors, and higher compared to unmethylated-BRCA-wt tumors (BRCA-wt-unmeth; P < 0.001). Platinum-refractory or -resistant HGOCs at first recurrence were all BRCA-unmeth cancers. Only one of the BRCA-mut cancers had a platinum-resistant recurrence. Thus, 99% of relapses in cancers with epigenetic or genetic BRCA-alterations were platinum-sensitive. Multivariate analysis confirmed BRCA-LOF as an independent predictor of progression-free survival (PFS) and overall survival (OS), whereas HRD-status had no predictive value for PFS and OS. Patients with BRCA-wt-unmeth cancers had the worst outcome compared to patients with cancers harboring epigenetic or genetic BRCA-alterations (PFS: P = 0.007; OS: P = 0.022). Most importantly, the BRCA-wt-unmeth subfraction of HRD-positive HGOCs exhibited the same poor survival as the entire HRD-negative cohort.

Conclusion: In HGOC BRCA mutational status together with BRCA1-methylation exhibit the best predictive power for favorable clinical outcome and thus high sensitivity to platinum-based therapy, whereas BRCA-unrelated HRD positivity was not associated with improved platinum sensitivity.