To evaluate the actual role of extracellular fluid volume (ECFV) expansion per se in modulating the rate of urinary calcium excretion, a thermoneutral water immersion (WI) study was conducted in 10 normal subjects and 30 patients with essential hypertension. Central hypervolemia by 2 hours of WI caused a significant diuretic and natriuretic response (P < .005) in normal subjects; no significant changes were detected in urinary calcium and magnesium excretion. WI provoked either an appropriate or exaggerated natriuresis (P < .001) in 21 hypertensive patients; these subjects also exhibited a highly positive correlation between urinary sodium and calcium excretion during WI (P < .001). In the remaining nine hypertensive patients, WI produced a significant diuretic response, but a barely discernible (P = NS) natriuresis (inappropriate response). These subjects also exhibited a significant reduction of urinary calcium (P < .001) and magnesium (P < .01) excretion. The data indicate that (1) volume expansion per se may have a role in regulating calcium excretion in hypertensive subjects; (2) a calcium leak may be attributable to a close relationship between urinary sodium and calcium metabolism, and causally related to a disturbance of sodium and volume homeostasis in hypertension.