By the genetic localization of the first melanoma susceptibility gene on chromosome 1p we thought that the puzzle on familial melanoma families would soon be solved. Now, almost fifteen years later we have learned that inherited melanoma is not a simple genetic disorder and that multiple genes, modifying genes and environmental factors might be involved. This paper outlines the current understanding of the genetics of melanoma and the relationship to atypical nevi based on more than ten years of genetic analysis in the Dutch familial atypical multiple mole-melanoma (FAMMM) syndrome families.