Blocking the interaction of the CD28 costimulatory receptor with its ligands, CD80 and CD86, inhibits in vivo immune responses, such as allograft rejection, and in some instances induces tolerance. Previously, we found that CTLA4Ig, which blocks the CD28/CTLA-4 (CD152) ligands CD80 and CD86, can be used to induce transplantation tolerance to vascularized allografts. Recent data suggest that an intact CD152-negative signaling pathway is essential for induction of tolerance to nominal Ags. Here, we show that blockade of CD152 using an anti-CD152 mAb at the time of transplantation prevents the induction of long-term allograft survival by agents that target CD80 and CD86. In contrast, CD152 signals are not required for the maintenance of established graft survival. We also report for the first time that blockade of CD86 alone can induce long-term graft survival. This requires that anti-CD86 mAb is given on the day of transplantation and also depends upon an intact CD152 pathway. This result, plus experiments using CD80-deficient mice, suggests a dominant role for CD80 molecules on donor cells as the relevant ligand for CD152. We additionally find that blockade of CD152 at the time of transplantation does not interfere with the effectiveness of anti-CD154 mAbs, suggesting distinct mechanisms for inhibition of graft rejection by blocking the CD28 vs CD154 pathways.