-
Comprehensive Framework for Controlling Nonlinear Multi-Species Water Quality Dynamics
Authors:
Salma M. Elsherif,
Ahmad F. Taha,
Ahmed A. Abokifa,
Lina Sela
Abstract:
Tracing disinfectant (e.g., chlorine) and contaminants evolution in water networks requires the solution of 1- D advection-reaction (AR) partial differential equations (PDEs). With the absence of analytical solutions in many scenarios, numerical solutions require high-resolution time- and spacediscretizations resulting in large model dimensions. This adds complexity to the water quality control pr…
▽ More
Tracing disinfectant (e.g., chlorine) and contaminants evolution in water networks requires the solution of 1- D advection-reaction (AR) partial differential equations (PDEs). With the absence of analytical solutions in many scenarios, numerical solutions require high-resolution time- and spacediscretizations resulting in large model dimensions. This adds complexity to the water quality control problem. In addition, considering multi-species water quality dynamics rather than the single-species dynamics produces a more accurate description of the reaction dynamics under abnormal hazardous conditions (e.g., contamination events). Yet, these dynamics introduces nonlinear reaction formulation to the model. To that end, solving nonlinear 1-D AR PDEs in real time is critical in achieving monitoring and control goals for various scaled networks with a high computational burden. In this work, we propose a novel comprehensive framework to overcome the large-dimensionality issue by introducing different approaches for applying model order reduction (MOR) algorithms to the nonlinear system followed by applying real-time water quality regulation algorithm that is based on an advanced model to maintain desirable disinfectant levels in water networks under multi-species dynamics. The performance of this framework is validated using rigorous numerical case studies under a wide range of scenarios demonstrating the challenges associated with regulating water quality under such conditions.
△ Less
Submitted 13 July, 2023; v1 submitted 20 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Control-Theoretic Modeling of Multi-Species Water Quality Dynamics in Drinking Water Networks: Survey, Methods, and Test Cases
Authors:
Salma M. Elsherif,
Shen Wang,
Ahmad F. Taha,
Lina Sela,
Marcio H. Giacomoni,
Ahmed Abokifa
Abstract:
Chlorine is a widely used disinfectant and proxy for water quality (WQ) monitoring in water distribution networks (WDN). Chlorine-based WQ regulation and control aims to maintain pathogen-free water. Chlorine residual evolution within WDN is commonly modeled using the typical single-species decay and reaction dynamics that account for network-wide, spatiotemporal chlorine concentrations only. Prio…
▽ More
Chlorine is a widely used disinfectant and proxy for water quality (WQ) monitoring in water distribution networks (WDN). Chlorine-based WQ regulation and control aims to maintain pathogen-free water. Chlorine residual evolution within WDN is commonly modeled using the typical single-species decay and reaction dynamics that account for network-wide, spatiotemporal chlorine concentrations only. Prior studies have proposed more advanced and accurate descriptions via multi-species dynamics. This paper presents a host of novel state-space, control-theoretic representations of multi-species water quality dynamics. These representations describe decay, reaction, and transport of chlorine and a fictitious reactive substance to reflect realistic complex scenarios in WDN. Such dynamics are simulated over space- and time-discretized grids of the transport partial differential equation and the nonlinear reaction ordinary differential equation. To that end, this paper (i) provides a full description on how to formulate a high fidelity model-driven state-space representation of the multi-species water quality dynamics and (ii) investigates the applicability and performance of different Eulerian-based schemes (Lax-Wendroff, backward Euler, and Crank- Nicolson) and Lagrangian-based schemes (method of characteristics) in contrast with EPANET and its EPANET-MSX extension. Numerical case studies reveal that the Lax-Wendroff scheme and method of characteristics outperform other schemes with reliable results under reasonable assumptions and limitations.
△ Less
Submitted 31 May, 2022; v1 submitted 29 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
Model Order Reduction for Water Quality Dynamics
Authors:
Shen Wang,
Ahmad F. Taha,
Ankush Chakrabarty,
Lina Sela,
Ahmed Abokifa
Abstract:
A state-space representation of water quality dynamics describing disinfectant (e.g., chlorine) transport dynamics in drinking water distribution networks has been recently proposed. Such representation is a byproduct of space- and time-discretization of the PDE modeling transport dynamics. This results in a large state-space dimension even for small networks with tens of nodes. Although such a st…
▽ More
A state-space representation of water quality dynamics describing disinfectant (e.g., chlorine) transport dynamics in drinking water distribution networks has been recently proposed. Such representation is a byproduct of space- and time-discretization of the PDE modeling transport dynamics. This results in a large state-space dimension even for small networks with tens of nodes. Although such a state-space model provides a model-driven approach to predict water quality dynamics, incorporating it into model-based control algorithms or state estimators for large networks is challenging and at times intractable. To that end, this paper investigates model order reduction (MOR) methods for water quality dynamics with the objective of performing post-reduction feedback control. The presented investigation focuses on reducing state-dimension by orders of magnitude, the stability of the MOR methods, and the application of these methods to model predictive control.
△ Less
Submitted 18 February, 2022; v1 submitted 21 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Revisiting the Water Quality Sensor Placement Problem: Optimizing Network Observability and State Estimation Metrics
Authors:
Ahmad F. Taha,
Shen Wang,
Yi Guo,
Tyler H. Summers,
Nikolaos Gatsis,
Marcio H. Giacomoni,
Ahmed A. Abokifa
Abstract:
Real-time water quality (WQ) sensors in water distribution networks (WDN) have the potential to enable network-wide observability of water quality indicators, contamination event detection, and closed-loop feedback control of WQ dynamics. To that end, prior research has investigated a wide range of methods that guide the geographic placement of WQ sensors. These methods assign a metric for fixed s…
▽ More
Real-time water quality (WQ) sensors in water distribution networks (WDN) have the potential to enable network-wide observability of water quality indicators, contamination event detection, and closed-loop feedback control of WQ dynamics. To that end, prior research has investigated a wide range of methods that guide the geographic placement of WQ sensors. These methods assign a metric for fixed sensor placement (SP) followed by \textit{metric-optimization} to obtain optimal SP. These metrics include minimizing intrusion detection time, minimizing the expected population and amount of contaminated water affected by an intrusion event. In contrast to the literature, the objective of this paper is to provide a computational method that considers the overlooked metric of state estimation and network-wide observability of the WQ dynamics. This metric finds the optimal WQ sensor placement that minimizes the state estimation error via the Kalman filter for noisy WQ dynamics -- a metric that quantifies WDN observability. To that end, the state-space dynamics of WQ states for an entire WDN are given and the observability-driven sensor placement algorithm is presented. The algorithm takes into account the time-varying nature of WQ dynamics due to changes in the hydraulic profile -- a collection of hydraulic states including heads (pressures) at nodes and flow rates in links which are caused by a demand profile over a certain period of time. Thorough case studies are given, highlighting key findings, observations, and recommendations for WDN operators. Github codes are included for reproducibility.
△ Less
Submitted 9 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
How Effective is Model Predictive Control in Real-Time Water Quality Regulation? State-Space Modeling and Scalable Control
Authors:
Shen Wang,
Ahmad F. Taha,
Ahmed A. Abokifa
Abstract:
Real-time water quality control (WQC) in water distribution networks (WDN), the problem of regulating disinfectant levels, is challenging due to lack of (i) a proper control-oriented modeling considering complicated components (junctions, reservoirs, tanks, pipes, pumps, and valves) for water quality modeling in WDN and (ii) a corresponding scalable control algorithm that performs real-time water…
▽ More
Real-time water quality control (WQC) in water distribution networks (WDN), the problem of regulating disinfectant levels, is challenging due to lack of (i) a proper control-oriented modeling considering complicated components (junctions, reservoirs, tanks, pipes, pumps, and valves) for water quality modeling in WDN and (ii) a corresponding scalable control algorithm that performs real-time water quality regulation. In this paper, we solve the WQC problem by (a) proposing a novel state-space representation of the WQC problem that provides an explicit relationship between inputs (chlorine dosage at booster stations) and states/outputs (chlorine concentrations in the entire network) and (b) designing a highly scalable model predictive control (MPC) algorithm that showcases fast response time and resilience against some sources of uncertainty.
△ Less
Submitted 16 December, 2020; v1 submitted 2 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.