-
Characterization of the ELM-free Negative Triangularity Edge on DIII-D
Authors:
A. O. Nelson,
L. Schmitz,
T. Cote,
J. F. Parisi,
S. Stewart,
C. Paz-Soldan,
K. E. Thome,
M. E. Austin,
F. Scotti,
J. L. Barr,
A. Hyatt,
N. Leuthold,
A. Marinoni,
T. Neiser,
T. Osborne,
N. Richner,
A. S. Welander,
W. P. Wehner,
R. Wilcox,
T. M. Wilks,
J. Yang
Abstract:
Tokamak plasmas with strong negative triangularity (NT) shaping typically exhibit fundamentally different edge behavior than conventional L-mode or H-mode plasmas. Over the entire DIII-D database, plasmas with sufficiently negative triangularity are found to be inherently free of edge localized modes (ELMs), even at injected powers well above the predicted L-H power threshold. A critical triangula…
▽ More
Tokamak plasmas with strong negative triangularity (NT) shaping typically exhibit fundamentally different edge behavior than conventional L-mode or H-mode plasmas. Over the entire DIII-D database, plasmas with sufficiently negative triangularity are found to be inherently free of edge localized modes (ELMs), even at injected powers well above the predicted L-H power threshold. A critical triangularly ($δ_\mathrm{crit}\simeq-0.15$), consistent with inherently ELM-free operation is identified, beyond which access to the second stability region for infinite-$n$ ballooning modes closes on DIII-D. It is also possible to close access to this region, and thereby prevent an H-mode transition, at weaker average triangularities ($δ\lesssimδ_\mathrm{crit}$) provided that at least one of the two x-points is still sufficiently negative. Enhanced low field side magnetic fluctuations during ELM-free operation are consistent with additional turbulence limiting the NT edge gradient. Despite the reduced upper limit on the pressure gradient imposed by ballooning stability, NT plasmas are able to support small pedestals and are typically characterized by an enhancement of edge pressure gradients beyond those found in traditional L-mode plasmas. Further, the pressure gradient inside of this small pedestal is unusually steep, allowing access to high core performance that is competitive with other ELM-free regimes previously achieved on DIII-D. Since ELM-free operation in NT is linked directly to the magnetic geometry, NT fusion pilot plants are predicted to maintain advantageous edge conditions even in burning plasma regimes, potentially eliminating reactor core-integration issues caused by ELMs.
△ Less
Submitted 17 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
ELM-free Enhanced Dα H-mode with Near Zero NBI Torque Injection in DIII-D Tokamak
Authors:
T. Macwan,
K. Barada,
J. F. Parisi,
R. Groebner,
T. L. Rhodes,
S. Banerjee,
C. Chrystal,
Q. Pratt,
Z. Yan,
H. Wang,
L. Zeng,
M. E. Austin,
N. A. Crocker,
W. A. Peebles
Abstract:
Enhanced $D_α$ H-mode (EDA H-mode), an ELM-free H-mode regime, is explored in neutral beam heated, lower single null plasmas with near zero torque injection. This regime exhibits a good energy confinement ($\mathrm{H}_{\mathrm{98y2}}$ $\sim 1$) with $β_N \sim 2$, high density, regime access at low input power, and no ELMs. This paper further presents the time-resolved measurements of electron and…
▽ More
Enhanced $D_α$ H-mode (EDA H-mode), an ELM-free H-mode regime, is explored in neutral beam heated, lower single null plasmas with near zero torque injection. This regime exhibits a good energy confinement ($\mathrm{H}_{\mathrm{98y2}}$ $\sim 1$) with $β_N \sim 2$, high density, regime access at low input power, and no ELMs. This paper further presents the time-resolved measurements of electron and ion density, temperature, plasma rotation, and radial electric field during the EDA H-mode phase and examines the dynamics of the edge quasi-coherent mode (QCM). Measurements using multiple fluctuation diagnostics reveal the QCM to be a separatrix spanning mode, peaking just inside the separatrix, existing in a wide range of $k_{\perp}ρ_s \sim 0.1-1.2$ with multiple harmonics, and propagating with a very small phase velocity in the plasma frame, where $k_{\perp}$ is the binormal wavenumber and $ρ_s$ is the ion sound radius. Linear gyrokinetic simulations of an EDA H-mode discharge with CGYRO indicates that the trapped electron mode (TEM) and electron temperature gradient (ETG) are dominant instabilities in the region where QCM is unstable. Qualitative analysis indicates that the properties of TEM are consistent with the experimental observed characteristics of the QCM. These similarities suggest that the QCM might be a TEM instability existing in the edge region of the EDA H-mode plasmas.
△ Less
Submitted 9 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Prospects of negative triangularity tokamak for advanced steady-state confinement of fusion plasmas
Authors:
Linjin Zheng,
M. T. Kotschenreuther,
F. L. Waelbroeck,
M. E. Austin,
W. L. Rowan,
P. Valanju,
X. Liu
Abstract:
The steady-state confinement, beta limit, and divertor heat load are among the most concerned issues for toroidal confinement of fusion plasmas. In this work, we show that the negative triangularity tokamak has promising prospects to address these issues. We first demonstrate that the negative triangularity tokamak generates the filed line rotation transform more effectively. This brings bright pr…
▽ More
The steady-state confinement, beta limit, and divertor heat load are among the most concerned issues for toroidal confinement of fusion plasmas. In this work, we show that the negative triangularity tokamak has promising prospects to address these issues. We first demonstrate that the negative triangularity tokamak generates the filed line rotation transform more effectively. This brings bright prospects for the advanced steady-state tokamak scenario. Given this, the stability and confinement features of negative triangularity tokamak are investigated. We point out that the negative triangularity configuration with a broad pressure profile is indeed more unstable for low-n magnetohydrodynamic modes than the positive triangularity case so that the H-mode confinement can hardly be achieved in this configuration, where n is the toroidal mode number. Nevertheless, we found that the negative triangularity configuration with high bootstrap current fraction, high poloidal beta, and peaked pressure profiles can achieve higher normalized beta for low-n modes than the positive triangularity case. In a certain parameter domain, the normalized beta can reach about twice the extended Troyon limit, while the same computation indicates that the positive triangularity configuration is indeed constrained by the Troyon limit. This shows that the negative triangularity tokamaks are not only favorable for divertor design to avoid the edge localized modes but also can have promising prospects for advanced steady-state confinement of fusion plasmas in high beta.
△ Less
Submitted 27 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Simultaneous access to high normalized current, pressure, density, and confinement in strongly-shaped diverted negative triangularity plasmas
Authors:
C. Paz-Soldan,
C. Chrystal,
P. Lunia,
A. O. Nelson,
K. E. Thome,
M. E. Austin,
T. B. Cote,
A. W. Hyatt,
A. Marinoni,
T. H. Osborne,
M. Pharr,
O. Sauter,
F. Scotti,
T. M. Wilks,
H. S. Wilson
Abstract:
Strongly-shaped diverted negative triangularity (NT) plasmas in the DIII-D tokamak demonstrate simultaneous access to high normalized current, pressure, density, and confinement. NT plasmas are shown to exist across an expansive parameter space compatible with high fusion power production, revealing surprisingly good core stability properties that compare favorably to conventional positive triangu…
▽ More
Strongly-shaped diverted negative triangularity (NT) plasmas in the DIII-D tokamak demonstrate simultaneous access to high normalized current, pressure, density, and confinement. NT plasmas are shown to exist across an expansive parameter space compatible with high fusion power production, revealing surprisingly good core stability properties that compare favorably to conventional positive triangularity plasmas in DIII-D. Non-dimensionalizing the operating space, edge safety factors below 3, normalized betas above 3, Greenwald density fractions above 1, and high-confinement mode (H-mode) confinement qualities above 1 are simultaneously observed, all with a robustly stable edge free from deleterious edge-localized mode instabilities. Scaling of the confinement time with engineering parameters reveals at least a linear dependence on plasma current although with significant power degradation, both in excess of expected H-mode scalings. These results increase confidence that NT plasmas are a viable approach to realize fusion power and open directions for future detailed study.
△ Less
Submitted 7 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Robust avoidance of edge-localized modes alongside gradient formation in the negative triangularity tokamak edge
Authors:
A. O. Nelson,
L. Schmitz,
C. Paz-Soldan,
K. E. Thome,
T. B. Cote,
N. Leuthold,
F. Scotti,
M. E. Austin,
A. Hyatt,
T. Osborne
Abstract:
In a series of high performance diverted discharges on DIII-D, we demonstrate that strong negative triangularity (NT) shaping robustly suppresses all edge-localized mode (ELM) activity over a wide range of plasma conditions: $\langle n\rangle=0.1-1.5\times10^{20}$m$^{-3}$, $P_\mathrm{aux}=0-15$MW and $|B_\mathrm{t}|=1-2.2$T, corresponding to $P_\mathrm{loss}/P_\mathrm{LH08}\sim8$. The full dataset…
▽ More
In a series of high performance diverted discharges on DIII-D, we demonstrate that strong negative triangularity (NT) shaping robustly suppresses all edge-localized mode (ELM) activity over a wide range of plasma conditions: $\langle n\rangle=0.1-1.5\times10^{20}$m$^{-3}$, $P_\mathrm{aux}=0-15$MW and $|B_\mathrm{t}|=1-2.2$T, corresponding to $P_\mathrm{loss}/P_\mathrm{LH08}\sim8$. The full dataset is consistent with the theoretical prediction that magnetic shear in the NT edge inhibits access to ELMing H-mode regimes; all experimental pressure profiles are found to be at or below the infinite-$n$ ballooning stability limit. Importantly, we also report enhanced edge pressure gradients at strong NT that are significantly steeper than in traditional ELM-free L-mode plasmas and provide significant promise for NT reactor integration.
△ Less
Submitted 22 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Energetic Electron Transport in Magnetic Fields with Island Chains and Stochastic Regions
Authors:
E G Kostadinova,
D M Orlov,
M Koepke,
F Skiff,
M E Austin
Abstract:
This paper investigates energetic electron transport in magnetized toroidal plasmas with magnetic fields characterized by island chains and regions of stochastic field lines produced by coil perturbations. We report on experiments performed in the DIII-D tokamak, which utilize electron cyclotron heating and current drive pulses to tag electron populations within different locations across the disc…
▽ More
This paper investigates energetic electron transport in magnetized toroidal plasmas with magnetic fields characterized by island chains and regions of stochastic field lines produced by coil perturbations. We report on experiments performed in the DIII-D tokamak, which utilize electron cyclotron heating and current drive pulses to tag electron populations within different locations across the discharge. The cross-field transport of these populations is then inferred from electron cyclotron emission measurements and gamma emission signals from scintillator detectors. Two types of energetic particles are distinguished and discussed: nonrelativistic suprathermal electrons and relativistic runaway electrons. The magnetic field topology in each discharge is reconstructed with field line tracing codes, which are also used to determine the location and scale of magnetic islands and stochastic regions. Comparison of simulations and experiments suggests that suprathermal transport is suppressed when the tagging is performed at a smaller radial location than the location of the q=1 island chain, and enhanced otherwise. We further demonstrate that increasing the width of the stochastic region within the edge plasma yields enhancement of the suprathermal electron transport.
△ Less
Submitted 3 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Investigation of Core Transport Barriers in DIII-D Discharges with off-axis Te Profile Peaks
Authors:
Ruifeng Xie,
Max E. Austin,
Kenneth W. Gentle,
Craig C. Petty
Abstract:
DIII-D discharges that transition to H-mode solely with off-axis electron cyclotron heating (ECH) often exhibit strong off-axis peaking of electron temperature profiles at the heating location. Electron heat transport properties near these off-axis temperature peaks have been studied using modulated ECH. The Fourier analyzed electron temperature data have been used to infer electron thermal diffus…
▽ More
DIII-D discharges that transition to H-mode solely with off-axis electron cyclotron heating (ECH) often exhibit strong off-axis peaking of electron temperature profiles at the heating location. Electron heat transport properties near these off-axis temperature peaks have been studied using modulated ECH. The Fourier analyzed electron temperature data have been used to infer electron thermal diffusivity. Comparisons with numerical solutions of the time-dependent electron thermal equation find that the data are consistent with a narrow region with electron diffusivity $χ_e$ an order of magnitude lower than the average value across the plasma, suggesting an electron internal transport barrier (ITB) near the ECH heating location. Detailed profile analysis and equilibrium reconstructions suggest that the formation of these ITBs are correlated with off-axis values of the safety factor $q$ being near 1. Furthermore, the ECH driven H-mode discharges demonstrate more rapid electron heating rate near the ECH deposition location than L-mode discharges with higher auxiliary ECH heating power. Additional modeling attributes this difference to the modification of electron heat transport in the core at the L-H transition, which also sustains the off-axis electron temperature peaks.
△ Less
Submitted 18 October, 2023; v1 submitted 12 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
The deteriorating effect of plasma density fluctuations on microwave beam quality
Authors:
Alf Köhn,
Max E. Austin,
Michael W. Brookman,
Kenneth W. Gentle,
Lorenzo Guidi,
Eberhard Holzhauer,
Rob J. La Haye,
Jarrod B. Leddy,
Omar Maj,
Craig C. Petty,
Emanuele Poli,
Terry L. Rhodes,
Antti Snicker,
Matthew B. Thomas,
Roddy G. L. Vann,
Hannes Weber
Abstract:
Turbulent plasma edge density fluctuations can broaden a traversing microwave beam degrading its quality. This can be a problem for scenarios relying on a high spatial localization of the deposition of injected microwave power, like controlling MHD instabilities. Here we present numerical estimations of the scattering of a microwave beam by density fluctuations over a large parameter range, includ…
▽ More
Turbulent plasma edge density fluctuations can broaden a traversing microwave beam degrading its quality. This can be a problem for scenarios relying on a high spatial localization of the deposition of injected microwave power, like controlling MHD instabilities. Here we present numerical estimations of the scattering of a microwave beam by density fluctuations over a large parameter range, including extrapolations to ITER. Two codes are used, the full-wave code IPF-FDMC and the wave kinetic equation solver WKBeam. A successful comparison between beam broadening obtained from DIII-D experiments and corresponding full-wave simulations is shown.
△ Less
Submitted 24 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
-
The effects of kinetic instabilities on the electron cyclotron emission from runaway electrons
Authors:
Chang Liu,
Lei Shi,
Eero Hirvijoki,
Dylan P. Brennan,
Amitava Bhattacharjee,
Carlos Paz-Soldan,
Max E. Austin
Abstract:
In this paper we show that the kinetic instabilities associated with runaway electron beams play an essential role for the production of high-level non-thermal electron-cyclotron-emission (ECE) radiation. Most of the non-thermal ECE comes from runaway electrons in the low-energy regime with large pitch angle, which are strongly scattered by the excited whistler waves. The power of ECE from runaway…
▽ More
In this paper we show that the kinetic instabilities associated with runaway electron beams play an essential role for the production of high-level non-thermal electron-cyclotron-emission (ECE) radiation. Most of the non-thermal ECE comes from runaway electrons in the low-energy regime with large pitch angle, which are strongly scattered by the excited whistler waves. The power of ECE from runaway electrons is obtained using a synthetic diagnostic model based on the reciprocity method. The electron distribution function is calculated using a kinetic simulation model including the whistler wave instabilities and the quasilinear diffusion effects. Simulations based on DIII-D low-density discharge reproduces the rapid growth of the ECE signals observed in DIII-D experiments. Unlike the thermal ECE where radiation for a certain frequency is strongly localized inside the resonance region, the non-thermal ECE radiation from runaway electrons is nonlocal, and the emission-absorption ratio is higher than that of thermal electrons. The runaway electron tail is more significant for ECE with higher frequencies, and the ECE spectrum becomes flatter as RE population grows. The nonlinear behavior of the kinetic instabilities is illustrated in the osculations of the ECE waves. The good agreement with the DIII-D experimental observations after including the kinetic instabilities clearly illustrate the significance of the scattering effects from wave-particle interactions, which can also be important for runaway electrons produced in disruptions.
△ Less
Submitted 27 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
-
Resolving ECRH deposition broadening due to edge turbulence in DIII-D by heat deposition measurement
Authors:
Michael W Brookman,
Matthew B Thomas,
Jarrod Leddy,
C Craig Petty,
Robert J La Haye,
K Barada,
Terry L Rhodes,
Zheng Yan,
Max E Austin,
Roddy G L Vann
Abstract:
Interaction between microwave power, used for local heating and mode control, and density fluctuations can produce a broadening of the injected beam, as confirmed in experiment and simulation. Increased power deposition width could impact suppression of tearing mode structures on ITER. This work discusses the experimental portion of an effort to understand scattering of injected microwaves by turb…
▽ More
Interaction between microwave power, used for local heating and mode control, and density fluctuations can produce a broadening of the injected beam, as confirmed in experiment and simulation. Increased power deposition width could impact suppression of tearing mode structures on ITER. This work discusses the experimental portion of an effort to understand scattering of injected microwaves by turbulence on the DIII-D tokamak. The corresponding theoretical modeling work can be found in M.B. Thomas et. al.: Submitted to Nuclear Fusion (2017)[Author Note - this paper to be published in same journal]. In a set of perturbative heat transport experiments, tokamak edge millimeter-scale fluctuation levels and microwave heat deposition are measured simultaneously. Beam broadening is separated from heat transport through fitting of modulated fluxes. Electron temperature measurements from a 500 kHz, 48-channel ECE radiometer are Fourier analyzed and used to calculate a deposition-dependent flux. Consistency of this flux with a transport model is evaluated. A diffusive and convective transport solution is linearized and compared with energy conservation-derived fluxes. Comparison between these two forms of heat flux is used to evaluate the quality of ECRF deposition profiles, and fitting finds a significant broadening of 1D equilibrium ray tracing calculations from the benchmarked TORAY-GA ray tracing code is needed. The physical basis, cross-validation, and application of the heat flux method is presented. The method is applied to a range of DIII-D discharges and finds a broadening factor of the deposition profile width which scales linearly with edge density fluctuation level. These experimental results are found to be consistent with the full-wave beam broadening measured by the 3D full wave simulations in the same discharges.
△ Less
Submitted 10 October, 2017;
originally announced October 2017.
-
Resolving ECRH deposition broadening due to edge turbulence in DIII-D by 3D full-wave simulations
Authors:
Matthew B Thomas,
Michael W Brookman,
Max E Austin,
Alf Köhn,
Robert J La Haye,
Jarrod B Leddy,
Roddy G L Vann,
Zheng Yan
Abstract:
Edge plasma density fluctuations are shown to have a significant effect on the electron cyclotron resonance heating (ECRH) beam in the DIII-D tokamak. Experimental measurements of the ECRH deposition profile have been taken in three operating scenarios: L-mode, H-mode and negative triangularity. Each scenario corresponds to distinct turbulence characteristics in the edge region through which the b…
▽ More
Edge plasma density fluctuations are shown to have a significant effect on the electron cyclotron resonance heating (ECRH) beam in the DIII-D tokamak. Experimental measurements of the ECRH deposition profile have been taken in three operating scenarios: L-mode, H-mode and negative triangularity. Each scenario corresponds to distinct turbulence characteristics in the edge region through which the beam must propagate. The measured ECRH deposition profile is significantly broadened by comparison to the profile predicted by the ray tracing code TORAY-GA and has been shown to scale with the severity of edge turbulence. Conventional ray tracing does not include the effects of turbulence and therefore a 3D full-wave cold plasma finite difference time domain code EMIT-3D is presented and used for the simulations. The turbulence is generated through the Hermes model in the BOUT++ framework which takes as input the measured time averaged electron density, temperature and magnetic field profiles for the specific shot in question. The simulated turbulence is constrained to match the experimentally measured (by use of the BES and DBS systems) correlation length and normalised fluctuation levels. The predictions of the beam broadening from the simulations are found to agree very well with the experimentally-observed broadening in all cases: L-mode, H-mode and negative triangularity. Due to the large gradients within the H-mode edge, the resolution uncertainty and error in the measurement from Thomson scattering and BES diagnostics result in a spread in the simulated turbulence amplitude. In light of this a parameter scan through the range in experimental diagnostic measurement uncertainty has been conducted to explore the impact on beam broadening predictions.
△ Less
Submitted 9 October, 2017;
originally announced October 2017.
-
Oblique electron-cyclotron-emission radial and phase detector of rotating magnetic islands applied to alignment and modulation of electron-cyclotron-current-drive for neoclassical tearing mode stabilization
Authors:
F. Volpe,
M. E. Austin,
G. Campbell,
T. Deterly
Abstract:
A two channel oblique electron cyclotron emission (ECE) radiometer was installed on the DIII-D tokamak and interfaced to 4 gyrotrons. Oblique ECE was used to toroidally and radially localize rotating magnetic islands and so assist their electron cyclotron current drive (ECCD) stabilization. In particular, after manipulations operated by the interfacing analogue circuit, the oblique ECE signals dir…
▽ More
A two channel oblique electron cyclotron emission (ECE) radiometer was installed on the DIII-D tokamak and interfaced to 4 gyrotrons. Oblique ECE was used to toroidally and radially localize rotating magnetic islands and so assist their electron cyclotron current drive (ECCD) stabilization. In particular, after manipulations operated by the interfacing analogue circuit, the oblique ECE signals directly modulated the current drive in synch with the island rotation and in phase with the island O-point, for a more efficient stabilization. Apart from the different toroidal location, the diagnostic view is identical to the ECCD launch direction,which greatly simplified the real-time use of the signals. In fact, a simple toroidal extrapolation was sufficient to lock the modulation to the O-point phase. This was accomplished by a specially designed phase shifter of nearly flat response over the 1-7kHz range. Moreover, correlation analysis of two channels slightly above and below the ECCD frequency allowed checking the radial alignment to the island, based on the fact that for satisfactory alignment the two signals are out of phase.
△ Less
Submitted 27 February, 2013;
originally announced February 2013.