-
Cost Allocation for Set Covering: the Happy Nucleolus
Authors:
Jannis Blauth,
Antonia Ellerbrock,
Vera Traub,
Jens Vygen
Abstract:
We consider cost allocation for set covering problems. We allocate as much cost to the elements (players) as possible without violating the group rationality condition (no subset of players pays more than covering this subset would cost), and so that the excess vector is lexicographically maximized. This is identical to the well-known nucleolus if the core of the corresponding cooperative game is…
▽ More
We consider cost allocation for set covering problems. We allocate as much cost to the elements (players) as possible without violating the group rationality condition (no subset of players pays more than covering this subset would cost), and so that the excess vector is lexicographically maximized. This is identical to the well-known nucleolus if the core of the corresponding cooperative game is nonempty, i.e., if some optimum fractional cover is integral. In general, we call this the 'happy nucleolus'. Like for the nucleolus, the excess vector contains an entry for every subset of players, not only for the sets in the given set covering instance. Moreover, it is NP-hard to compute a single entry because this requires solving a set covering problem. Nevertheless, we give an explicit family of at most $mn$ subsets, each with a trivial cover (by a single set), such that the happy nucleolus is always completely determined by this proxy excess vector; here $m$ and $n$ denote the number of sets and the number of players in our set covering instance. We show that this is the unique minimal such family in a natural sense. While computing the nucleolus for set covering is NP-hard, our results imply that the happy nucleolus can be computed in polynomial time.
△ Less
Submitted 2 August, 2024; v1 submitted 8 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Improved guarantees for the a priori TSP
Authors:
Jannis Blauth,
Meike Neuwohner,
Luise Puhlmann,
Jens Vygen
Abstract:
We revisit the a priori TSP (with independent activation) and prove stronger approximation guarantees than were previously known. In the a priori TSP, we are given a metric space $(V,c)$ and an activation probability $p(v)$ for each customer $v\in V$. We ask for a TSP tour $T$ for $V$ that minimizes the expected length after cutting $T$ short by skipping the inactive customers. All known approxima…
▽ More
We revisit the a priori TSP (with independent activation) and prove stronger approximation guarantees than were previously known. In the a priori TSP, we are given a metric space $(V,c)$ and an activation probability $p(v)$ for each customer $v\in V$. We ask for a TSP tour $T$ for $V$ that minimizes the expected length after cutting $T$ short by skipping the inactive customers. All known approximation algorithms select a nonempty subset $S$ of the customers and construct a master route solution, consisting of a TSP tour for $S$ and two edges connecting every customer $v\in V\setminus S$ to a nearest customer in $S$. We address the following questions. If we randomly sample the subset $S$, what should be the sampling probabilities? How much worse than the optimum can the best master route solution be? The answers to these questions (we provide almost matching lower and upper bounds) lead to improved approximation guarantees: less than 3.1 with randomized sampling, and less than 5.9 with a deterministic polynomial-time algorithm.
△ Less
Submitted 19 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
A Better-Than-1.6-Approximation for Prize-Collecting TSP
Authors:
Jannis Blauth,
Nathan Klein,
Martin Nägele
Abstract:
Prize-Collecting TSP is a variant of the traveling salesperson problem where one may drop vertices from the tour at the cost of vertex-dependent penalties. The quality of a solution is then measured by adding the length of the tour and the sum of all penalties of vertices that are not visited. We present a polynomial-time approximation algorithm with an approximation guarantee slightly below…
▽ More
Prize-Collecting TSP is a variant of the traveling salesperson problem where one may drop vertices from the tour at the cost of vertex-dependent penalties. The quality of a solution is then measured by adding the length of the tour and the sum of all penalties of vertices that are not visited. We present a polynomial-time approximation algorithm with an approximation guarantee slightly below $1.6$, where the guarantee is with respect to the natural linear programming relaxation of the problem. This improves upon the previous best-known approximation ratio of $1.774$. Our approach is based on a known decomposition for solutions of this linear relaxation into rooted trees. Our algorithm takes a tree from this decomposition and then performs a pruning step before doing parity correction on the remainder. Using a simple analysis, we bound the approximation guarantee of the proposed algorithm by $(1+\sqrt{5})/2 \approx 1.618$, the golden ratio. With some additional technical care we further improve it to $1.599$.
△ Less
Submitted 14 February, 2024; v1 submitted 11 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
An improved approximation guarantee for Prize-Collecting TSP
Authors:
Jannis Blauth,
Martin Nägele
Abstract:
We present a new approximation algorithm for the (metric) prize-collecting traveling salesperson problem (PCTSP). In PCTSP, opposed to the classical traveling salesperson problem (TSP), one may not include a vertex of the input graph in the returned tour at the cost of a given vertex-dependent penalty, and the objective is to balance the length of the tour and the incurred penalties for omitted ve…
▽ More
We present a new approximation algorithm for the (metric) prize-collecting traveling salesperson problem (PCTSP). In PCTSP, opposed to the classical traveling salesperson problem (TSP), one may not include a vertex of the input graph in the returned tour at the cost of a given vertex-dependent penalty, and the objective is to balance the length of the tour and the incurred penalties for omitted vertices by minimizing the sum of the two. We present an algorithm that achieves an approximation guarantee of $1.774$ with respect to the natural linear programming relaxation of the problem. This significantly reduces the gap between the approximability of classical TSP and PCTSP, beating the previously best known approximation factor of $1.915$. As a key ingredient of our improvement, we present a refined decomposition technique for solutions of the LP relaxation, and show how to leverage components of that decomposition as building blocks for our tours.
△ Less
Submitted 12 April, 2023; v1 submitted 7 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Vehicle Routing with Time-Dependent Travel Times: Theory, Practice, and Benchmarks
Authors:
Jannis Blauth,
Stephan Held,
Dirk Müller,
Niklas Schlomberg,
Vera Traub,
Thorben Tröbst,
Jens Vygen
Abstract:
We develop theoretical foundations and practical algorithms for vehicle routing with time-dependent travel times. We also provide new benchmark instances and experimental results. First, we study basic operations on piecewise linear arrival time functions. In particular, we devise a faster algorithm to compute the pointwise minimum of a set of piecewise linear functions and a monotonicity-preservi…
▽ More
We develop theoretical foundations and practical algorithms for vehicle routing with time-dependent travel times. We also provide new benchmark instances and experimental results. First, we study basic operations on piecewise linear arrival time functions. In particular, we devise a faster algorithm to compute the pointwise minimum of a set of piecewise linear functions and a monotonicity-preserving variant of the Imai-Iri algorithm to approximate an arrival time function with fewer breakpoints.
Next, we show how to evaluate insertion and deletion operations in tours efficiently and update the underlying data structure faster than previously known when a tour changes. Evaluating a tour also requires a scheduling step which is non-trivial in the presence of time windows and time-dependent travel times. We show how to perform this in linear time.
Based on these results, we develop a local search heuristic to solve real-world vehicle routing problems with various constraints efficiently and report experimental results on classical benchmarks. Since most of these do not have time-dependent travel times, we generate and publish new benchmark instances that are based on real-world data. This data also demonstrates the importance of considering time-dependent travel times in instances with tight time windows.
△ Less
Submitted 25 March, 2024; v1 submitted 2 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
Improving the Approximation Ratio for Capacitated Vehicle Routing
Authors:
Jannis Blauth,
Vera Traub,
Jens Vygen
Abstract:
We devise a new approximation algorithm for capacitated vehicle routing. Our algorithm yields a better approximation ratio for general capacitated vehicle routing as well as for the unit-demand case and the splittable variant. Our results hold in arbitrary metric spaces. This is the first improvement upon the classical tour partitioning algorithm by Haimovich and Rinnooy Kan and Altinkemer and Gav…
▽ More
We devise a new approximation algorithm for capacitated vehicle routing. Our algorithm yields a better approximation ratio for general capacitated vehicle routing as well as for the unit-demand case and the splittable variant. Our results hold in arbitrary metric spaces. This is the first improvement upon the classical tour partitioning algorithm by Haimovich and Rinnooy Kan and Altinkemer and Gavish.
△ Less
Submitted 10 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.